Vice President J.D. Vance did not rule out the possibility of President Donald Trump invoking the Insurrection Act when asked directly about it in a Sunday interview.
“Are you seriously considering invoking the Insurrection Act?” host Kristen Welker asked Vance on NBC’s “Meet the Press” as the two discussed the deployment of troops to U.S. cities.
“Well, the president’s looking at all of his options,” Vance responded. “Right now, he hasn’t felt he needed to.”
The vice president’s comments come as Trump raised the prospect of using the Insurrection Act last week and as NBC News has reported that the move has been under discussion among White House officials.
“If I had to enact it, I would do that,” Trump previously said on Oct. 6, describing it as a potential workaround in case judges stymie his deployments. “If people were being killed and courts were holding us up, or governors or mayors were holding us up.”
“White House officials have held increasingly serious discussions in recent days about President Donald Trump’s invoking the Insurrection Act,” NBC News reported on Oct. 8.
The invocation of this law would mark a significant escalation and could be ripe for serious abuse, legal experts say. Under the Insurrection Act, the president can deploy the military to address a rebellion or civil unrest, though it’s rarely been enacted. If activated, troops would be able to participate in law enforcement activities they’re typically barred from, such as making arrests and conducting searches.
The law was last utilized in 1992 in response to riots in Los Angeles after California’s then-governor requested assistance.
Sources told NBC that there have been concerns that the White House’s invocation of the law wouldn’t presently stand up to U.S. Supreme Court scrutiny and that aides aim to exhaust other options first.
And legal experts have warned that presidents could weaponize the law and called for more restrictions on how it can be used. “An army turned inward can very quickly become an instrument of tyranny,” Elizabeth Goitein, senior director of the Liberty and National Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice, told NPR in 2024.
Vance emphasized Sunday that the administration was intent on continuing to push for the deployment of the National Guard in Chicago, despite opposition from local leaders and court decisions that have restricted the move. He said that the rationale for doing so was based on purported concerns about crime and violence toward immigration enforcement agents.
“The problem here is not the Insurrection Act or whether we actually invoke it or not,” Vance said on “Meet The Press,” while disparaging the media and its alleged condoning of violence toward law enforcement.
Local leaders, including Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker and Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson, have repeatedly stated that they don’t need the National Guard in the city and that it has seen major declines in its violent crime rate this year.
On Saturday, an appeals court ruled that National Guard troops federalized in Illinois could remain in the state, but couldn’t be deployed for now. That follows District Court Judge April Perry, noting that she didn’t observe a “danger of rebellion” in the state as Trump surges federal agents there.
“We’re obviously going to litigate this as much as we can,” Vance said during a Sunday interview on ABC’s “This Week”. “We think that we have the authority to provide proper safety to our citizens all over the United States, but particularly in Chicago.”
