One night last September, Rihanna Kelver, a trans activist and former bartender living in Laramie, Wyoming, pointed her gun at a group of men after they allegedly verbally harassed her before shoving her to the ground. Although she claims to have drawn her gun in self-defense while she was down — and did not fire any shots — she was arrested and charged with aggravated assault and possession of a deadly weapon, which could land her up to 15 years in prison, according to The New York Times.
The confrontation began “when the man across the street allegedly shouted anti-LGBTQ+ and anti-transgender slurs,” Kelver told the Laramie Reporter before her preliminary hearing this past May. The details of this terrifying interaction — which Kelver described in an interview with the Reporter — are pretty ghastly.
But they also bring up a lot of feelings about how queer people are often held to double standards when it comes to rules that are meant to protect “everyone.”
Wyoming is a “stand your ground” state, referring to legislation meant to protect gun owners who act in self-defense. Police listed the man Kelver pointed her gun at, Scott Durham, as the victim in this case. But in security camera footage released by the Times, the men don’t appear to be scared at all, and Kelver never even touched them during the interaction.
Wyoming’s “stand your ground” law was passed in 2018 and allows gun owners to fire a weapon “if they reasonably believed that they faced an imminent threat of harm.” And so, denying this legal carveout to Kelver clearly shows us who the government actually deems worthy of “self-defense,” who is granted the benefit of the doubt, and, by extension, who is allowed to defend their own life.
When it comes to criminal behavior, queer and trans people often experience negative bias compared to their straight and cisgender counterparts. This is reflected by the fact that queer and trans people are disproportionately represented in the prison system. We also live in a country where one of our two main political parties is hellbent on portraying trans people as an existential threat.
There is a specific sort of violence that follows trans women around — one that stems from a perceived threat to cis, straight men’s masculinity. In fact, more trans people have been buying guns as a result of widespread attacks on their rights and concerns for their safety.
All of this comes at a time when alarmist conversations about trans people and guns are reaching a fever pitch. There are conspiracy theories claiming that trans people are prone to being shooters, a lie that is dangerous and misleading. Out of hundreds of mass shootings recorded in recent years, about five cases, or 0.1-0.2%, have been perpetrated by trans or nonbinary people, according to GLAAD. Most mass shootings have been carried out by cisgender men.
Everyone should be paying attention to Kelver’s case. It represents an insidious bias against not just queer people, but Black and Latine gun owners as well. Straight white gun owners will vehemently champion the right to bear arms for self-defense. But the minute anyone else wants to exercise that right, they’re potential criminals.
As we watch the case play out, it’s crucial to keep this bias in mind, especially when we assess the kind of violence that Kelver might have been anticipating.
