
It only takes a few minutes of watching “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” to understand why it’s so popular.
The show follows a group of Mormon mom TikTok influencers and friends whose social circle and worlds implode after one of them, Taylor Frankie Paul, reveals she and her husband had been “soft-swinging” with other Mormon couples. That sends their group, #MomTok, into a swinging sex scandal, generating international headlines. The first season chronicles the fallout. It is messy and captivating.
Season 2 of the Hulu reality series debuted earlier this month and amassed 5 million views in the first five days of streaming globally on Hulu and Disney+. The signs that “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” has infiltrated the zeitgeist are visible everywhere. The show has been trending across social media platforms since the new season started. I realized it was reaching all kinds of viewers when the same person who told me to watch Zeus Network’s “Baddies” is presently singing the praises of the TikTok Mormon mamas in texts across the land.
It’s been well established now that Mormons and their culture make for captivating television. This was true with HBO’s bigamy-based “Big Love” and later in reality with Bravo’s “The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City,” which, through some of its stars like Heather Gay, highlights how the religion has brought harm to their lives.
Yet, while the religion has been chronicled on TV before, there is nothing like “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.” As messy as their lives are, they’re still making money, and, thanks to the TV series, are making more money than ever. In Season 2, Miranda McWhorter, one of the women from the scandal who was missing from Season 1, has joined the cast. She is not greeted warmly. Most of the #MomTok crew believes Miranda is only around for the money and clout.
“The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” has sparked discourse around cultural representation of Utah and the Mormon faith. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints issued a rare commentary ahead of the release of the first season of the show, attacking it for promoting stereotypes about Mormonism.
On that criticism, one cast member, Layla Taylor, told The Salt Lake Tribune this month: “We’re not trying to say that this is what Mormons are. We’re trying to say that this is individual people’s journey within the faith, and we’re not trying to generalize it.”

Layla’s castmates have expressed similar sentiments, and as they all see it, they are working to change perceptions of Mormons and “fight the patriarchy” through #MomTok. Some of the women have discussed how their faith had taught them to prioritize the needs and happiness of the men in their lives, but with all of the money they are making from #MomTok, their stances have changed.
One husband happily became a stay-at-home dad after learning how much his wife makes. How much? His entire yearly salary is one of her brand deals. A lot of men, fooled by the patriarchy and the incel nonsense they consume online, would stand to benefit from thinking less like a Neanderthal.
Among those men include Zac Affleck, husband of Jen Affleck, who was more or less a monster to his wife throughout the first season. In Season 2, Zac has apparently taken a break from med school (which his wife pays for with her TikTok money or was gifted to him by his family) in order to win her back.
Jen is struggling with being submissive to her husband, as taught by the church, and wants to be equals if they are to move forward. Annoying as he was in Season 1, he has taken a break from the church himself and is doing ketamine therapy with her on camera.
Part of me wonders if he’s only recognizing how expensive life is without a rich and famous wife, but Zac does, at least, call Jen on her mess. Say, confronting her over lying about being related to Ben Affleck, and later, over claiming to be from “the hood.”
But Zac’s biggest shade is for #MomTok. After finding out some of the group is icing his wife out, Zac tells Jen: “It’s almost like you’re trapped because it’s your business.”
Jen says she hangs on because of what #MomTok could be.
“All you guys do is talk s**t about each other,” Zac replies.
So much s**t that Whitney Leavitt, the villain of Season 1, quotes Ephesians 4:32 in the confessional: “Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, just as God in Christ has forgiven you.”
It’s fairly obvious that there are financial incentives for this friend group to exist, but their relationships and camaraderie appear far more genuine than most of these types of shows. Even if they aren’t exactly always being the beacon of light they claim to want to be in the world, they’re willing to be forthright about it on camera in ways a lot of older, more social-media-conscious TV personalities aren’t.
In one scene, Taylor’s family effectively slut-shames her over her cheating baby daddy; it takes a long while to free oneself from the prison of male appeasement when brought up by ding-dongs.
If there is any complaint, perhaps it would be that dropping 10 hourlong episodes at once might stifle buzz-building. Then again, “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” is a fascinating exploration of faith, celebrity, gender dynamics and social media that is like nothing I’ve ever seen before.
It is not preordained that the show will continue to be a ratings behemoth, but Season 2 suggests it probably will be.
