
Re: the Kelly Clarkson SELF cover kerfuffle.
Before I address SELF, to be fair, I want to refer to Lauren Collins' article from the May 12, 2008 issue of The New Yorker entitled, "Pixel Prefect" because it has stayed with me since I read it.
In it Collins delivers the how-can-it-be news that even Christy Turlington isn't Christy Turlington-y enough for fashion photography:
Pascal Dangin is the premier retoucher of fashion photographs. Art
Directors and admen call him when they want someone who looks less than
great to look great, someone who looks great to look amazing, or someone
who looks amazing already... to look, as is the mode, superhuman. (Christy
Turlington, for the record, needs the least help.) In the March issue of
Vogue Dangin tweaked a hundred and forty-four images: a hundred and
seven advertisements (Estee Lauder, Gucci, Dior, etc.), thirty-six fashion pictures
and the cover, featuring Drew Barrymore...Vanity Fair, W, Harper's
Bazaar, Allure, French Vogue, Italian Vogue, V, and the Times Magazine, among others, also use Dangin.
We've come to expect this from magazines, but the layered irony of SELF's message was too lush to pass up:
Irony One: You don't even have to bring your self to the photo shoot. They'll make you a fake one.
Irony Two: Clarkson is on the cover as The Most Inspiring Woman of 2009. For eating disorder inspiration.
Irony Three: The issue is focused on "Total Body Confidence." Unless you have a real one.
Irony Four: The cover photo is the money shot. But since Clarkson is famous for her singing, off the shelf sales will largely be due to fans of her musical ability. Yet SELF takes the focus off her talent by making us focus on what they see as the money shot... a version of Clarkson that doesn't exist. They don't see the real woman as talented, pretty and skinny enough to bring in revenue.
In an interview on the Today Show with SELF's Editor in Chief Lucy Danziger and the model Emme, the issue was debated. Emme suggested that because so many women are expressing outrage at all the retouching, we should use this as an opportunity to hear that women want to see a variety of body types represented in magazines. Danziger defended her position with illogical certainty:
"SELF says 'Love your self'... We love [Kelly] for the confidence she exudes from within...You want a cover to capture the essence of you at your best so we're saying to women, 'Look: Everyone can love who they are from the inside out and want to achieve your goals.'"
What size is your essence?
