Action News Wire

A U.S. Territory With Complicated Trump Ties Is In Crisis — And No One Is Talking About It

“If I didn’t think about it too much, it was almost like we were camping. These days it’s not as easy to fool myself.”

A U.S. Territory With Complicated Trump Ties Is In Crisis — And No One Is Talking About It

“Would you rather live without water, or without power?”

A friend asked me this question last year, at a small New Year’s gathering in Puerto Rico that I’d been invited to at the very last minute, after the electrical grid abruptly shut down all over the densely populated metro area of San Juan. The hosts were throwing the party at an apartment with a generator running to keep the lights on, so we could have some music to dance to, cold drinks from the fridge, and see the ball drop on TV at midnight.

When my friend asked me the question, we were huddled together on the apartment’s outdoor balcony, staring out into the sea of darkness of the city around us. It was another night without power, not that unusual for Puerto Ricans. The island’s electrical grid has been struggling since Hurricane Maria in 2016, when millions of Puerto Ricans were left without electricity for nearly a year, and has not improved much since the government turned operations over to a private Canadian utility firm, LUMA, a move that has been riddled with accusations of mismanagement and corruption.

What made this outage particularly frustrating was that we had made plans to go out and celebrate, hoping that on New Year’s we might catch a break, and now here we were, all dressed up to greet 2025 in the dark. Trying to keep the mood light, the question turned our predicament into a kind of game — a “would you rather” scenario that we just so happened to be playing out in real time.

We volleyed back and forth, listing the pros and cons of living without water or no power. No water means no showers, no washing dishes, no laundry, and worst of all: no flushing toilets. It doesn’t take long before your house starts smelling like a litter box. No power means no air conditioning, no charging electronics, no lights to see at night, appliances breaking down and medicines that need to be refrigerated going to waste. The game isn’t that fun, to be honest. There are no real winners, just varying degrees of losing.

That night, I chose no power. I’m a Puerto Rican who grew up in Florida, where frequent hurricanes left us without light for months at a time, and we’d managed to get by with candles and barbecue grills OK enough. I was a kid then and liked that I didn’t have to go to school during long outages. If I didn’t think about it too much, it was almost like we were camping. These days it’s not as easy to fool myself.

The question came up again last week, over a year and a half since I first played the game. I was at a beach in San Juan, with the same friend from New Year’s, who had invited me for an impromptu potluck. This time, I was the one who asked for it. This time, instead of no light, there was no water. My friend, Jose, had been living without it for a whole month and just got it back. I am in my third week and still have none. Both of us know people who’ve gone even longer without it.

Sunset at a beach in San Juan, Puerto Rico.
Sunset at a beach in San Juan, Puerto Rico.
Courtesy of Edgar Gomez

There are a number of reasons for the water crisis in Puerto Rico. If you ask the governor, Jenniffer González, she’ll say it’s because of the drought we’re experiencing on the island. An ally of President Donald Trump, she declared a state of emergency on July 31, prompting many to recall Hurricane Maria, when Trump visited Puerto Rico and callously threw rolls of paper towels at suffering locals.

The drought certainly contributes to the crisis, though others are also quick to point out aging infrastructure problems, specifically the fact that 59% of the water collected by the aqueduct that supplies San Juan is lost by the Puerto Rico Aqueduct and Sewer Authority due to “inaccurate meters, unauthorized water consumption, or water main leaks.” Even when it does rain, Puerto Ricans are left in the dry.

And then there is the long history of displacement: ever since the United States invaded Puerto Rico in 1898, the country has been on a mission to create a Puerto Rico without Puerto Ricans. From the U.S. Supreme Court calling natives savages, to U.S. corporations decimating local agriculture, the government at points outlawing Puerto Ricans from speaking Spanish or waving the flag, even going as far as sterilizing approximately one-third of the women on the island between the 1930s and the 1970s.

The latest approach to displacement has been through gentrification, in the form of granting enormous tax breaks to non-Puerto Ricans who move to the island, many of whom purchase properties to convert into Airbnbs, resulting in fewer and more expensive housing options for locals. Earlier this month, at his final concert for his Debi Tomar Mas Fotos Tour, Bad Bunny encouraged his fans to attend a protest in Cabo Rojo, on the southwest coast of the island, where González recently passed several measures to fast-track the much-contested Esencia project, a multi-billion-dollar luxury residential and resort development. Critics of Esencia say it will further strain precious water resources across the island, as well as threaten protected coastal ecosystems and contribute to the issue of privatization of beaches.

“Las playas son del pueblo” — the beaches belong to the people — is a common refrain heard among local activists, who fear losing access to the island’s beaches, which are constitutionally designated as belonging to the public. The fear hits close to home. In the neighboring Caribbean island Jamaica, less than 1% of the nation’s coastline is freely open to the public. If they want to go to the beach, many Jamaicans have to purchase day passes from resorts.

The author, in Luquillo, Puerto Rico.
The author, in Luquillo, Puerto Rico.
Photo by E.R.C.

At the beach in San Juan, my friend Jose and I watched the waves rolling in, a momentary reprieve from not having water at home. I thought of the famous line from the poem “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge: “Water water everywhere, nor any drop to drink.”

At the start of the drought, González rolled out an emergency water rationing system, dividing San Juan into zones that would have water for two days, then no water for two days, alternating until the crisis ended. When I first read about the rationing system, I groaned, imagining the stacks of dirty dishes that were about to collect in my sink, the smell of urine I’d have to let collect in the toilet and that in no time would overrun my entire house. I laugh now at my naivety. I would love to ration water, if that’s still an option!

“It’s really like two days suffering, two days crying, two days screaming, two days praying for a trickle,” Jose joked. The reality is that for many of us there hasn’t really been water at all.

As we played our “would you rather” game, I told him about my routine. I’ve been getting by through a combination of buying gallons of water in bulk from Costco, showering at my gym (which has a water cistern that they pay to fill up), and lots and lots of moist towelettes (one of the other heartbreaking things about water outages is the secondary damage to the environment, since we are forced to rely on disposable dishware and sanitary products).

I am relatively young, able-bodied, and don’t have children, so I can manage. But what do you do if you’re a parent and have to change your baby’s diaper? If you’re a caregiver and need to bathe someone who has had an accident? If you operate a local business? If you’re a nurse at a hospital? If you can’t afford a gym membership or lots and lots of moist towelettes?

Those with money have bought cisterns to address the water crisis and solar panels to deal with the electricity issues. But the working-class person? Resolvemos, we say around here. You just... resolve. You figure it out. Last week, when it rained for an hour, I ran outside to “shower” in my driveway in my swim trunks. This week, I noticed a small drip from my bathtub faucet, so I put a bucket under it to collect the drops, which I’ve been using to brush my teeth and flush the toilet. My friend Jose’s water came back on a few days ago. He’s invited me to do laundry at his place and refill some gallon jugs there — at least while he has the water to offer. Resolvemos.

"This is a bucket I have rigged to my bathtub faucet," the author writes. "It's collecting drops of water to use to brush my teeth and do dishes."
"This is a bucket I have rigged to my bathtub faucet," the author writes. "It's collecting drops of water to use to brush my teeth and do dishes."
Courtesy of Edgar Gomez

We get by, little by little. We play our game, though in my weaker moments during this latest drought, it’s felt like the government is really playing a game on us. Puerto Ricans don’t have water or power. The power to change this situation, while the island is run to the ground by politicians who ignore our basic needs. The power to fight to live with dignity, when it can be hard enough to get through a day without showers or toilets or clean clothes.

I know that isn’t true — there is a lot of fight in Puerto Rico. I just have to remind myself sometimes, and look around at the movements happening all over the island led by folks who refuse to be pushed out of their homes. The students who shut down the University of Puerto Rico earlier this year protesting budget cuts. The thousands who showed up to march against Esencia in Cabo Rojo.

Just last month, to celebrate her 50th birthday, González threw a series of lavish birthday parties/campaign fundraisers at hotels in San Juan. Protestors gathered outside of the events, calling her and her guests “corrupt” and “traitors” and voicing their frustration over the water crisis. At one fundraiser, a protestor threw water at an event organizer, a bold, symbolic gesture that has been celebrated by some and criticized by others.

For my part, I wonder where they got that water. Did they have to go out and buy it, or did they collect it from a leaking faucet, like I’m doing in my bathtub? What I do know is that there are millions of Puerto Ricans who are tired of being disrespected and played with, whether it’s electricity, gentrification or our underfunded universities. This latest water crisis is just a drop in the bucket of our collective frustration. I hope to be here when it overflows.

Edgar Gomez is the author of the critically-acclaimed memoir “Alligator Tears” (Crown Publishing, 2025), which was called “triumphant, dazzling, and unfailing stylish” by Publisher’s Weekly, and “High-Risk Homosexual” (Soft Skull Press, 2022), for which he received The American Book Award and a Lambda Literary Award. He has written for The Los Angeles Times, Poets & Writers, New York Magazine, and beyond. Gomez splits his time between New York and Puerto Rico.

Do you have a compelling personal story you’d like to see published on HuffPost? Find out what we’re looking for here and send us a pitch at pitch@huffpost.com.