Action News Wire

This Is What Happens When You Test Positive For Marijuana After Giving Birth In Idaho

Keeva Rossow is one of hundreds of women who have been punished for purported "child abuse" of a fetus — despite giving birth to a healthy baby.

This Is What Happens When You Test Positive For Marijuana After Giving Birth In Idaho
Illustration: HuffPost; Photos: Getty

Keeva Rossow had no idea when she arrived at an Idaho hospital to give birth in December 2021 that she may not leave with her daughter.

Shortly after Rossow gave birth, a social worker stopped by her hospital room and asked a series of questions, including if she had used controlled substances while pregnant. She told the social worker that she had used THC, or marijuana, for pregnancy-related nausea. Her morning sickness was so severe she had started losing weight, which she knew wasn’t healthy for her or her pregnancy, and the anti-nausea medication her doctor prescribed hadn’t helped.

Rossow didn’t think much of it at the time. The questions felt routine, and she assumed her answers were protected under medical privacy laws, according to Rossow’s attorney, Rick Hearn, whom HuffPost interviewed for this story.

She gave birth to a perfectly healthy baby girl.

Later, as she was recovering, a worker from Child Protective Services and a uniformed police officer came to Rossow’s hospital room. They told her that because she had admitted to prenatal drug use she would be placed on the Idaho Child Protection Central Registry ― the state government’s list of people substantiated for child abuse, neglect or abandonment. She would remain on the registry for a minimum of 10 years. The CPS worker told Rossow they would come to her home to do a welfare check, and that her daughter would be taken from her if she was ever found to be using drugs again.

Rossow was stunned and confused. She had been open with her physician throughout her pregnancy that she was using THC to treat her morning sickness. When the social worker asked her all of those questions, she assumed her answers were protected under HIPAA. She was not told she had the right to decline to answer, or that her answers could lead to such a devastating outcome.

The Idaho Department of Health and Welfare, which oversees the state’s Child Protection Central Registry and Child Protective Services, told HuffPost it does not comment on pending litigation.

What happened to Rossow has happened to dozens of other women in Idaho, and hundreds more around the country. Around 20 other states have similar registries that define prenatal substance use as child abuse. The statutes are meant to protect children, but they pertain to fetuses. By defining Rossow’s THC use as child abuse or child neglect, Idaho has effectively implemented a backdoor fetal personhood statute.

Fetal personhood statutes give fetuses the same rights and protected class status as any other child under the age of 18. The anti-abortion movement has been trying for decades to pass personhood laws that would reinterpret when life legally begins and instantly criminalize abortion at all stages of pregnancy. The idea that fetuses should be treated as people is the foundation of pregnancy criminalization.

Despite continued attempts, Republicans in Congress and state legislatures have failed to successfully actualize any full-blown personhood law, even as they’ve pushed through many abortion bans. But personhood language has still permeated dozens of child protection lawst across the country, often by defining prenatal drug use as a type of child abuse.

Lawmakers created these statutes ostensibly to curb substance use during pregnancy and protect the health of the mother and fetus ― a welcomed and rational goal. But in reality, these statutes surveil and criminalize women like Rossow, making pregnant people second-class citizens to the very fetuses they carry. These policies are not effective. In practice, experts told HuffPost, they can deter pregnant people from seeking necessary health care, resulting in an uptick of unhealthy birth outcomes like preterm birth and low birth weight.

Rossow is now the face of a lawsuit that argues Idaho’s decision to place her on the child abuse registry is unconstitutional. She says her right to due process was violated, in part because the “child” she allegedly abused was not a child at all but a fetus. The suit was certified as a class-action lawsuit earlier this year, and includes any woman who has been or will be put on Idaho’s Child Protection Central Registry for prenatal THC use. Rossow and Serah Thompson, another Idaho woman who was added to the registry for prenatal THC use, are the two named plaintiffs in the class-action suit.

“At its heart, [this case] is about fairness,” Idaho Senate Minority Leader Melissa Wintrow (D) told HuffPost.

“It asks whether the state can quietly label someone a child abuser, without a hearing, without proof of harm, just because they were pregnant,” she said. “This case is a chance for Idaho to affirm that no one loses their rights just because they’re expecting a child. It’s about dignity, due process, and standing up for people when the system gets it wrong.”

“This case is a chance for Idaho to affirm that no one loses their rights just because they're expecting a child. It's about dignity, due process, and standing up for people when the system gets it wrong.”

- State Sen. Melissa Wintrow (D)

‘Child Abuse’ In Utero

There are 23,587 people on Idaho’s Child Protection Central Registry, as of Monday, according to the state’s Department of Health and Welfare. Of those, 3,041 were listed on the confidential registry because of prenatal use of a controlled substance. In the last two months, 23 people were added to the Idaho list because of controlled substance use while pregnant, according to public records request.

From 2021 to 2024, there was a 45% increase of women added to Idaho’s Child Protection Registry for substance use while pregnant, according to an Investigate West report that linked much of this increase to the 2022 Supreme Court decision that repealed federal abortion protections.

Idaho’s Department of Health and Welfare does not track how many of the 3,000 are for THC use. The list is confidential unless an employer requests a background check. Hearn, who has seen the list as part of the discovery process for Rossow’s lawsuit, told HuffPost “the vast majority” is for THC.

Like Rossow, many women who use marijuana during pregnancy do so to address morning sickness and other pregnancy symptoms, like headaches or a loss of appetite, sometimes because they’re facing barriers to other forms of care. Research on the impacts THC has on fetal development is limited, though the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommends that people not use marijuana during pregnancy.

Two weeks after Rossow gave birth to her baby girl, she received a letter from Idaho’s Child Welfare agency informing her she had been officially put on the state’s registry for child abusers, court documents show. She posed “a medium to high risk to children” in the eyes of the Idaho government because she had used marijuana during her pregnancy. Rossow appealed the decision but was denied.

Any future employer who does a background check on Rossow will find that she’s on the state’s child abuse registry — but not why.

“[The list] doesn’t come back and say you used edibles or you smoked marijuana while pregnant,” Hearn explained. “It comes back and says you’re on a list of child abusers… which includes people who beat up their kids or killed them. It doesn’t say you are a little bit on there. It just comes back and says you’re on there.”

Rossow said in her deposition that she had planned to apply to nursing school, but she knows she won’t get in because her name is on the registry. She has since given up on her dream of becoming a nurse.

“This feeds into the narrative that you can't actually trust women to make the best choices for themselves and their pregnancies and their families.”

- Wendy Heipt, Legal Voice

The state substantiated that Rossow had used THC while pregnant by conducting a test of the umbilical cord blood ― a process hospitals commonly use to assess a newborn’s health and spot any potential issues. Hearn said she did not consent to having her cord blood tested for THC.

Idaho established prenatal use of controlled substances as abuse, neglect or abandonment of a child in 2008. Lawmakers added the statute to the state’s child protection law, or the Child Protection Act, which defines a child as a person under the age of 18.

“It’s pretty clear that a fetus is not a child under the Child Protection Act,” Hearn said.

For using THC while pregnant, Rossow was given a Level Two designation ― the same category used for people substantiated for physical abuse of a child and “the confinement of a child that poses a substantial risk of causing life-threatening, disabling, or disfiguring injury.” A prospective employer cannot see the level designation Rossow was given, only that she is on the state’s child abuse registry.

The levels correspond to how long someone is on the registry before they can apply to be taken off: Level One is the most serious and anyone with this designation is on the registry for life; Level Two puts someone on the registry for a minimum of 10 years; and Level Three puts someone on the registry for a minimum of five years.

“This feeds into the narrative that you can’t actually trust women to make the best choices for themselves and their pregnancies and their families, and the state has to come in to protect pregnancies from the women,” Wendy Heipt, senior reproductive rights counsel at Legal Voice, told HuffPost. Heipt has written extensively about the threat of legal fetal personhood.

“It sets up this false argument, as if women are against their pregnancies, and the state has to tell them what to do.”

Personhood Chips Away At Pregnant People’s Rights

A federal law created in 2016 mandates that medical professionals notify child protection agencies when newborns are affected by prenatal drug use or exposure. Some states have taken that as a go-ahead to classify prenatal drug use as child abuse or neglect. This allows states to add new mothers to these child abuse registries or use prenatal substance use as evidence in criminal cases.

Hundreds of women were criminalized for their pregnancy outcomes long before Roe v. Wade fell. Between 2006 and June 2022, nearly 1,400 women were arrested for their behavior while pregnant, a 2023 report from Pregnancy Justice found. The majority of cases involved women using illicit substances or drinking alcohol while pregnant. Some of the more extreme cases included pregnant women being arrested for not wearing a seatbelt, refusing a C-section, and not getting prenatal care while HIV positive and pregnant. These more extreme instances reveal how fetal personhood ideology enacted into law quickly becomes a slippery slope.

“We can tie this increase in criminalization directly to the expansion of the increased ideology of fetal personhood: the idea that a fetus or a fertilized egg has the same, if not more, rights than the actual person carrying the pregnancy,” Lourdes Rivera, the president of Pregnancy Justice, told HuffPost when the report was published. “During the period that we’re looking at 2006 to June 2022, fetal personhood gained influence and has increasingly become embedded in laws in judicial decisions.”

Pregnancy criminalization in the U.S. became widespread following the 1970s’ “war on drugs” ― an explicitly racist political maneuvering that led to the now-debunked “crack baby epidemic.” Because of this, Black women were disproportionately criminalized in the first several decades after Roe was enacted.

While the makeup of criminalization rates have changed, pregnant women of color are often still surveilled at higher rates than white women. Rossow — who is white — was not charged criminally, but her experience is still an example of how the growing popularity of personhood ideology is slowly eating away at pregnant people’s rights.

Once viewed as something only the most radical anti-abortion fanatics believed in, fetal personhood has become more accepted as a mainstream principle within the anti-abortion movement. In Georgia, Republicans passed a near-total abortion ban less than a month after the fall of Roe that recognized a fetus as a person after six weeks of pregnancy. In Alabama, the state Supreme Court ruled last year that an embryo should have the same legal rights as a born child ― effectively criminalizing in vitro fertilization for several tumultuous weeks. Earlier this year, Republicans in Congress reintroduced the Life At Conception Act for the fifth time. The law, which calls for equal protection “of each born and preborn human person” under the 14th Amendment, has 131 Republican co-sponsors ― nearly 60% of all GOP members in the House.

Rossow isn’t the first mother to fight personhood statues that are hidden in child protection laws. In 2023, Lindsay Ridgell won a similar case after Arizona added her to its child abuse registry because she used THC to cure her pregnancy-related morning sickness. Ridgell was put on the list for a minimum of 25 years, and lost her job at the state’s Department of Child Safety. The Arizona state Supreme Court sided with the state’s court of appeals which found Ridgell’s marijuana use did not amount to child neglect. Ridgell, who was put on the child abuse registry in 2019 after giving birth, was removed in 2023.

The policies Rossow and Ridgell were penalized under aren’t actually effective, experts told HuffPost ― even for pregnant people who use harder drugs than marijuana. Sarah Roberts, a professor and legal epidemiologist at the University of California, San Francisco, said these types of policies force pregnant people to forgo prenatal care out of fear of being reported to child welfare or being criminalized by the state.

“Overall, these policies are ineffective in terms of improving or protecting the health and well-being of infants, and in some cases they’re actually harmful,” Roberts said. “I’ve been doing this research for more than a decade, and we haven’t found benefits to the policies.”

Child neglect is the main reason the vast majority of people are put on these state-level registries or have their children removed from their care. Kylee Sunderlin, legal services director at If/When/How’s Repro Legal Helpline, told HuffPost that somewhere around 80% of the allegations are based in neglect which is really just poverty.

“It’s all rooted in poverty,” Sunderlin said. “What they do is they put someone on a state central register, and they severely limit their job prospects and keep them in the loop of poverty.”

If Rossow wins her class-action suit, Idaho will have to stop putting pregnant people who test positive for prenatal THC use on the Child Protection Central Registry. The state would also have to remove Rossow and anyone else who has been put on the list for testing positive for marijuana use while pregnant.

Hearn, Rossow’s attorney, emphasized the very real risks Rossow and Thompson are taking on by bringing this suit against Idaho’s Department of Health and Welfare. “It’s scary for both of my clients. This is not under seal. Their names will be out there,” he said.

“Everybody will know they’re on a list of child abusers,” he added. “They’re volunteering to take the hit… in order to try to get them and everybody else off that list.”