Action News Wire

I Traveled The Country As A Christian Pop Singer. Behind The Scenes, I Was Hiding A Big Secret.

“There is, as we know, no turning back from disgust; once it sets in, it cannot be reversed or ignored.”

I Traveled The Country As A Christian Pop Singer. Behind The Scenes, I Was Hiding A Big Secret.
The author performing on her "Shatterproof" tour in 2017.
The author performing on her "Shatterproof" tour in 2017.
Photo Courtesy Of Julianna Glasse

I pushed up my sleeve and plunged my arm deep into the freezer. I felt around until I found the cool curve of the bottle. “There you are, my pretty,” I muttered as I pulled it up. I unscrewed the cap and took a healthy swig, the icy smoothness, full of promise, sliding down my gullet.

The cold vodka had the beautiful consistency of syrup as I poured a good stiff shot into my glass of sparkling water, screwed the cap back on, and returned the bottle to its place beneath the frozen vegetables and lamb chops. Until we meet again.

The single swallow hit my stomach and made my eyes water pleasantly. Courage and calm spread along my limbs, displacing my seething impatience. In the kitchen, I added my spiked drink to the tray of innocent glasses of sparkling water and carried the tray out to the living room and the assembled Bible study group.

I smiled, placed the tray on the table, and quickly picked up my “special” glass. I took a long drink. It was all I could do to not propose a toast: Here’s to critical thinking. None of you would know it if it bit you on the ass.

This was our Sunday night group, different from the ones held during the week. It was attended by both men and women, including my husband’s Major League teammates from the Chicago Cubs and their wives, and my husband and I led it together, along with the team-appointed “chaplain.”

Tonight’s topic was the travesty of women preaching from the pulpit. One of the men held forth about how this new wave of bogus feminazi pastors ordained in progressive churches was threatening to undermine God’s order — and civilization itself. Then he read a Bible verse to back up his position.

It was bad enough listening to him speak so arrogantly; worse was seeing the women nod and murmur in agreement. Last week it had been the scourge of gay marriage, and the week before that, a discussion of the eternal torments of hell.

I wanted to crawl out of my skin. But I sat quietly, sipping from my glass. What I felt was disgust. There is, as we know, no turning back from disgust; once it sets in, it cannot be reversed or ignored. It can be temporarily drowned or shoved aside, but it is not going to go away. So I hid it, just as I hid the vodka.

You might ask: How did I go from full-throated, Bible-thumping cheerleader for Christian “virtues” to squinty-eyed cynic sitting among the flock with a secret drink in her hand? Those hardline Evangelicals who want to keep women at home are quite right — if you let them out, they might learn about the world. They might start asking questions, they might get ideas and they might start thinking for themselves.

They might even leave the house in modest, demure attire and then change into colorful, vampy outfits in the car on the way to a musical event.

But I’m getting ahead of myself.

The author on stage during her 2017 tour.
The author on stage during her 2017 tour.
Photo Courtesy Of Julianna Glasse

It’s a great irony that it was when my star rose as a Christian pop singer, and I vigorously spread the gospel, that the seeds of rebellion were planted in me. But before rebellion comes doubt. A few years earlier, in one of my women’s Bible study groups in our living room, when we were talking about sex and the joy of service and submission — which at the time I still totally believed in and passionately advocated for — doubt reared its head in an abrupt and shocking way.

A woman who was new to our group had sat quietly, just listening, while other women spoke of husbands who required sex every night, or in the middle of the day, or both. Then the new woman in the group spoke up, shyly and softly.

“I think my husband is gay,” she said.

That got our attention.

“He makes me use a dildo on him,” she said. “To . . . you know, um . . . penetrate him. He says it’s my job to do this to keep him from sinning, from straying outside the marriage. I do it, but I really, really don’t like it.”

Until that moment, I thought I had heard everything, and I had thus far been able to find ways to help the women to accommodate their husbands’ various sexual requests, in the spirit of dutiful submission.

But her words stopped me cold. The other women did not speak, though I could feel a palpable wave of profound sympathy emanating from them.

My first reaction was a knee-jerk wave of antigay anger. I had been programmed for my entire life to believe that homosexuality was an abomination, a crime against God. How dare this man make his wife do something so grossly offensive as to make her a stand-in for a male partner? There was no possible way to make such an act fit the “joyful submission” model. To even try would be grotesque. It was, in a way, I thought, rape — of the wife, not the husband.

But further thought peeled away some uneasy layers. What forces compelled a gay man to marry a woman? And once he was married to a woman, what kept him from becoming heterosexual? How deeply ingrained was his sexual compulsion that even within the bounds of a straight marriage he was driven to satisfy those urges?

The answers that began to form themselves out of this confusion were not happy ones. If her husband was gay, it was because God had made him that way. And if God had made him that way, it should be within His power to change that man so that he would be satisfied with sex with a woman. But apparently He did not, or could not, change that man.

Instead, husband and wife, as believers, were locked in a cruel, painful arrangement, defined by the rules and requirements of the church and maintained by threats of social stigma and eternal damnation.

I could only imagine their hermetic little world of self-loathing, guilt, recrimination, fear, and suffering that festered away behind the figurative lace curtains and white picket fence of such a marriage.

How could this possibly be pleasing to God? I had no answer.

It felt like a cop-out to tell her to pray, though that’s what I did because I had not yet wrestled my doubts into anything resembling conviction. I prayed, too — for guidance, reassurance, some sort of help with this deeply troubling conundrum.

What I should have told her was for them to be kind to themselves, to set each other free.

After the birth of my son in 2009 came two more gorgeous children — my daughters, born in 2011 and 2015, respectively, during the soaring years of my career traveling around the country with my band, singing and witnessing for the Lord. My music ranged from prayerful and meditative to full-on rocking out: Nothing thrilled me more than seeing women being set free to dance, sing, clap, laugh and be with friends.

Again, I performed when I was pregnant, full of vigor and vitality, and I often took my babies on the road with me when they were still tiny. A caregiver would stay with them while I was out there onstage, in front of thousands of singing, praying, ecstatic, arm-waving people, the ones in the front row reaching for me to touch their hands so they could get a dose of that holy fire. Then, after the show, I would retire to the green room to nurse my baby before going out to the merch table to sign books and CDs.

The author connecting with fans on 2017's "Shatterproof" tour.
The author connecting with fans on 2017's "Shatterproof" tour.
Photo Courtesy Of Julianna Glasse

I loved it all. If I went to a baseball game, fans would yell my name as I walked through the concourse. I had to have security walk me to and from my seat. When I flew, people recognized me and pressed for autographs. I got stopped on the street — women sometimes leaning in close to tell me stories of how I had inspired them, helped them or transformed their lives.

Some of them proudly showed me their arms or backs, where they had tattooed the name of one of my songs on their bodies. It was infinitely gratifying to know I had touched actual lives, especially women’s.

When I arrived at a venue, I would be whisked to the green room by my runners, who were there to see that my every need was met. I would find tea, honey and healthy snacks awaiting me, as directed by my contract rider. Perhaps there would be a poster of my face on the wall, twinkle lights, and flowers.

As a Christian performer, I almost always had to sign a statement of faith before performing or speaking. I loved getting to sit with the pastors or promoters of the events and felt such camaraderie between us — we were coworkers for Christ, each of us doing what we could to spread the Word.

As my success grew, and I was performing at a wider range of churches, some of them much more progressive than others, those fabulous female runners began to offer more than tea and honey. They might greet me with a sly smile and say, “We left some chilled wine for you, for after the show.”

If I was not pregnant or nursing a baby, I partook. It felt so good, so freeing, so rewarding. So right. After all, didn’t Jesus turn water into wine?

One night, when the show was over and I had met with fans and producers and musicians and we had our customary session of praying, hugging and celebrating, a runner came up to me and spoke sotto voce: “We’re going out for cocktails. After the pastor leaves, of course,” she added with a wink. “Want to come?”

“Of course,” I said. And oh, the time we had — husbandless, our tongues loosened by margaritas or wine spritzers. With no constraints, we howled with laughter, told stories on ourselves and our spouses, confided fantasies, even cried.

After that, I must have been giving off some sort of stealth signal because I soon found myself getting invited out for a post-concert drink far more often than not, wherever I happened to travel. I was now, I realized, a member of a far-flung secret society. We love Jesus, but cuss a little bit. We have a little bubbly with our Bible study.

The author at rehearsal before an evening performance in 2016.
The author at rehearsal before an evening performance in 2016.
Photo Courtesy Of Julianna Glasse

Another night, I was greeted after the show by a group of fabulously dressed female fans in shiny, saucy, colorful outfits. “You are all so stunning,” I said to them. They laughed and told me their husbands would never have let them leave the house in the clothes they were wearing. They had brought their outfits with them and changed in the car for my show. They would change back into their regular husband-approved clothes on the way home. I was dazzled by their ingenuity and determination, but most of all, deeply honored. I had inspired them, and now they were inspiring me.

At still another show, I met a fan who was obviously gay — he was totally out, funny, and flamboyant. But he was married to a woman. I asked him why, and his answer saddened me.

“Well,” he said, “because homosexuality is a sin.”

And I thought: Is it? This guy was so authentic and beautiful in his element; he knew perfectly well who he was, but he was still caged by what were starting to look more and more to me like a set of unnecessary and destructive rules. And yet here I was, preaching the gospel to enormous crowds with my music.

The fissure ran deep. But it was clear that the tectonic plates were shifting. What I discovered, at my shows and on the road, was an underground community of awesome Christian women who were quietly liberating themselves. They were challenging me to join them, to free myself, to have a drink if I wanted one, to dress as I pleased, to push the boundaries, and most of all, to throw off the fear and judgment that lurked behind narrow beliefs.

I was beginning to see with terrible new clarity the damage done to people’s lives by these beliefs: the abuse, the repression, the suffering, all so unnecessary.

The author during a Sirius XM interview in 2016.
The author during a Sirius XM interview in 2016.
Photo Courtesy Of Julianna Glasse

I called this posse of extraordinary women my “Christian Drinkers.” I now counted myself among them. Not ready to toss faith entirely out the window, we still believed in the Lord but were boldly reinventing that faith. We had this radical notion that we could have freedom within the confines of the Word of God.

Maybe the Lord was not the rigid and vengeful God He had been made out to be. I wrote a speech called “Don’t Should on Me,” which talked about all the pressures and expectations the world puts on women and how to fight against them. I sold out of “Don’t Should on Me” merch regularly and often saw women at the airport wearing the merch the day after a show. My Christian Drinker ladies were like female prophets, and we were liberating each other together.

Other people saw what I was becoming more clearly than I saw myself. I will never forget the older woman who approached me after a show, looked me in the eye, and declared: “You’re an egalitarian, not a complementarian.”

In Evangelical-speak, she was saying that she could tell I believed that men and women are equal, even as I was trying to maintain the appearance of subservience to my husband. She had lived enough life to be able to tell I didn’t actually believe it.

Her assertion, delivered with such confidence, took me by surprise. Was she right? I looked inside, and though I had yet to fully articulate the belief to myself, I found that she possibly was.

When my youngest daughter was born in 2015, I was at home for a while resting and recovering, taking a break from performing. I was also at work on a book, a self-help tome for Christian women. For comparison, I looked at similar books.

One day, while I was nursing, I read “The Measure of a Woman” by the husband-and-wife team Gene and Elaine Getz. The subtitle, “What Really Makes a Woman Beautiful,” had already put me off. The book was heavy with Bible quotes pertaining to women and featured minibiographies of women in the Bible who, in the authors’ opinion, were paradigms of the various womanly traits under discussion, good and bad, from saints to Jezebels. The book hammered home the roles a godly Christian woman must fulfill: mother, mentor, memorizer, and reader, and most of all, of course, wife.

For a woman, the authors declared, a righteous life is one that consists of the recitation, memorization, and reading of God’s Word; then, when she is older and wiser, she will train up the young in godly ways.

What made this book a little different from all the others with essentially the same message was its emphasis on the importance of influencing other women. Yeah, I thought, another way of saying assisting in imprisoning them.

My reaction surprised me. Where had that come from?

I looked down at my newborn daughter, latched to my swollen breast. She was not a wife, perhaps never would be. She certainly was not a mother. She could not even speak yet, let alone mentor anyone. And for sure, she couldn’t read — not the Bible or anything else.

I was suddenly angry. According to the authors of this book, my daughter had, as yet, no purpose, no inherent worth, and neither did women who, for whatever reason, were not wives and mothers.

And I thought: Either my daughter has no value in and of herself, or this book, and all the others like it, are full of shit. I deeply resented the way the authors, in their sanctimonious tones, had mapped out my daughter’s entire life, right up to the time in the distant future when she would be an old lady in a rocking chair reciting verses from the Bible.

How dare they?

The author writing music at home.
The author writing music at home.
Photo Courtesy Of Julianna Glasse

My burgeoning doubt was like a big loose thread just begging to be pulled. I didn’t realize that when I pulled it, everything I believed would unravel. I was well into the book I was writing, and the publishers eagerly awaited it. But as I wrote, and as I experienced the world in my travels and contacts with my Christian Drinkers, my own written words were starting to look preachy, facile and even dishonest.

The contradictions in the central tenets of my faith were becoming impossible to ignore. I was starting to see, unhappily, the way the fundamental doctrine pertaining to inherent depravity and original sin were weaponized against humanity, women especially. I felt very protective of my children. I could never imagine teaching them that they were born fallible, defective, separate from God. I was holding my infant and, through tears, told her, “You are holy.”

I kept on writing, but strove to soften the more doctrinaire aspects of the book while staying within the bounds of the Christian agenda. It was a tricky high-wire act, let me tell you.

The spell was losing its grip, little by little. Looking back, I can identify an incident from that era that may have been the definitive one, from which there was no turning back.

My older daughter was about 6 at the time. She and her best friend, Hannah, a little girl from across the street, were scootering on the sidewalk near our home in Chicago. I was outside keeping an eye on them while I chatted with a neighbor.

The girls were about 50 feet away when I heard a loud smack, the clatter of their scooters and screams. They had collided with each other, banging their heads, and both had hit the pavement hard.

I raced to them. Never mind that the girls were wearing helmets; my daughter had a gash on her hand, and Hannah had fallen directly on her chin, abrading it badly. Blood was pouring out of both of them.

The author's very public and painful split from the church became her new memoir, "This Is What Happens When Women Read," out Oct. 13.
The author's very public and painful split from the church became her new memoir, "This Is What Happens When Women Read," out Oct. 13.
Photo Courtesy Of Spiegel & Grau

“Stay where you are!” I ordered the crying girls. I took off at top speed, crossing the street and yelling for Levi, Hannah’s dad, who was in his backyard a couple of houses down: “There’s been an accident!”

He heard me and came racing out from behind his house, and together we ran to our children. We were both praying aloud: he in Hebrew, because he was Jewish, and I in English.

Even as our feet pounded the ground and the world was a blur, a realization came to me: Each of us was praying to our separate God for the same thing: the safety and protection of our daughters.

Except that we could only be praying to the same God — because how else could it be?

It was a profound moment of shared humanity. And I thought: There’s no way I can tell this man that he is wrong for being Jewish, as Christian doctrine dictates — that I am somehow right, and he is not. It was just plain absurd and felt wildly arrogant.

In the time it took Levi and I to reach our daughters, you might say I underwent a conversion of sorts.

Their injuries were not life-threatening. Stitches and tender loving care had them back on their scooters in no time. But I was never exactly the same. On that day, I had outrun the dogma that was fundamental to my religion: that there is but one true God, and there was no other way to Him except through Jesus.

Still, I was not quite ready to come out of the closet. That would require the fullness of time.

Excerpted from THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN WOMEN READ by Julianna Glasse, published by Spiegel & Grau. Copyright © 2026 by Julianna Glasse. Used by permission

Do you have a compelling personal story you’d like to see published on HuffPost? Find out what we’re looking for here and send us a pitch at pitch@huffpost.com.