
WASHINGTON -- "Gang of eight" leaders Sens. John McCain (R-Ariz.) and Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said Thursday they are hoping for majority support from both parties for their comprehensive immigration bill, but a piecemeal approach -- particularly without a path to citizenship -- would doom it.
"What we're looking for, and I think the four of us Democrats in the room were mindful of this, is getting a large Republican vote," said Schumer, whose bipartisan gang of eight released an immigration reform bill last week, at an event hosted by the Christian Science Monitor.
"So we're looking not to get 61 votes ... Maybe this is hopeful, but it would be wonderful if we could get a majority on both sides," he added later, saying that could help pressure the House.
McCain said he thinks it's "very doable" to get that number of Republicans on board. The two said in January that they were aiming for 80 votes for their bill.
Still, they acknowledged it might be tough in the House, which is controlled by Republicans, many of whom are skeptical of reform. Just after the event, House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-Va.) and Immigration Subcommittee Chairman Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.) told reporters they planned a piecemeal approach that will begin soon, and so far they didn't have a bill that would legalize undocumented immigrants.
But McCain and Schumer agreed that a comprehensive approach is the only way to achieve immigration reform -- and that it must include a path to citizenship, not just legalization for undocumented immigrants.
"A legal status is not something that someone should have to remain in unless they want to," McCain said. "To say that you can have a legal status, but you can't have ... a path to become a citizen in this country, I just don't think [fits with] fundamental principles of fairness in our society. I don't understand -- I know that opposition is there, I don't think it's valid and I don't think it's held even by a majority of Republicans."
Schumer said there's no way a bill that didn't allow undocumented immigrants to become citizens would pass the Senate, and that it may not even get a single Democratic vote.
Both senators said they, and the other members of the gang of eight, would push back against amendments meant to kill the bill. They are open to others, they said, including anything that could increase national security in light of the attacks on the Boston Marathon last week. Those amendments have yet to be determined, McCain said, but he and Schumer agreed there would be plenty of time for senators to consider options before the bill goes to the Senate floor.
They also said they're not going to stand for those who try to use the Boston bombings to obstruct their bill.
"Those who say, in my judgment, 'Let's wait on the bill because we have to see everything that happened in Boston and see all of that' -- it's an excuse," Schumer said. "The only people who are saying that are people who were against the bill long before Boston occurred."
