Action News Wire

Jack Smith Throws Down Against Republicans In Public Hearing

The former special counsel defended his decisions to bring criminal charges against President Donald Trump.

Jack Smith Throws Down Against Republicans In Public Hearing

WASHINGTON ― Jack Smith has no regrets about pushing criminal charges against President Donald Trump, the former special counsel told lawmakers on Thursday.

“President Trump was charged because the evidence established that he willfully broke the law, the very laws that he took an oath to uphold,” Smith said in his opening statement before the House Judiciary Committee.

Smith secured two grand jury indictments against Trump for his schemes to overturn the 2020 presidential election result and his hoarding of classified documents after the end of his first term as president.

Since the Justice Department has a policy against prosecuting a sitting president, the cases went away after Trump returned to the White House, and Smith never had a chance to take Trump to trial. Thursday’s hearing was Smith’s first chance to defend his work in public ― and to square off against some of the Republicans who’ve spent years vilifying him for prosecuting some of the most obvious crimes in American history.

“Democrats have been going after President Trump for a decade, and the country should never, ever forget what they did,” House Judiciary Committee Chair Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) said in his opening statement, which claimed Smith used underhanded prosecutorial means in a purely political quest to keep Trump from getting back into the White House.

But even though Smith said he was eager to correct “false and misleading narratives” about his work, he spoke softly and avoided getting in arguments with lawmakers. The day’s most dramatic moment actually came during a break in the hearing when two members of the audience nearly got into a fight, a moment that was captured from multiple angles by C-SPAN cameras.

Former Washington Metropolitan Police Department officer Michael Fanone, left, and Ivan Raiklin, second from right, stand up and argue during a recess of testimony of former Justice Department special counsel Jack Smith before the House Judiciary Committee at the Capitol in Washington, Thursday, Jan. 22.
Former Washington Metropolitan Police Department officer Michael Fanone, left, and Ivan Raiklin, second from right, stand up and argue during a recess of testimony of former Justice Department special counsel Jack Smith before the House Judiciary Committee at the Capitol in Washington, Thursday, Jan. 22.
via Associated Press

Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), the committee’s top Democrat, said Republicans would only make fools of themselves by attacking Smith.

“They will only be stroking the wounded ego of the lawless, twice impeached, convicted felon president,” Raskin said, “who not only unleashed a mob against Congress and his own vice president, but has now pardoned and released into our communities, hundreds of extremists, insurrectionists and cop-beating felons who have proceeded to commit dozens more crimes against the American people since they were pardoned. ”

With four police officers who fought Trump’s mob on Jan. 6, 2021, sitting behind Smith in the hearing room, the former special counsel paused before giving answers and seemed determined to keep his testimony understated.

“Rather than accept his defeat in the 2020 presidential election, President Trump engaged in a criminal scheme to overturn the results and prevent the lawful transfer of power,” Smith said. “After leaving office in January 2021, President Trump illegally kept classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago social club after he left office, and he repeatedly tried to obstruct justice to conceal his continued retention of those documents.”

Republicans asked a number of questions about relatively trivial parts of Smith’s case against Trump, and sometimes they asked about things that were only tangentially related.

Jordan, for instance, asked Smith about Cassidy Hutchinson, the former White House aide who told the House Jan. 6 committee she’d heard secondhand that Trump was so mad his security detail wouldn’t take him to the Capitol that day, he lunged at his driver. Smith said he hadn’t confirmed her testimony, which has been disputed, but that he’d understood it to have been secondhand. He said that he hadn’t decided, before the case was dismissed, whether he’d call her as a witness.

“That says it all,” Jordan said. “That’s the degree the left and Democrats were willing to go to get President Trump: putting on the witness stand someone everybody knows is making it up.”

The indictment against Trump was based largely on direct witness testimony from dozens of Republicans, including several who said they’d told Trump themselves he’d lost the 2020 election. The disputed anecdote about the driver wasn’t part of it.

Another major Republican focus on Thursday was Smith’s decision to obtain “toll records” reflecting incoming and outgoing calls for several Republican members of Congress. Republicans have expressed outrage about the phone records, which did not include the actual content of their conversations, claiming it was an infringement of constitutional separation of powers between Congress and the executive branch.

Smith said he’d subpoenaed the records, without notifying the lawmakers, in accordance with Justice Department policy. He acknowledged the policy that the department changed in December 2024.

“You know why everyone knows it’s wrong? Because the public integrity section at the Justice Department has now changed its policy,” Jordan said.

The only catch? The department changed its policy after an internal watchdog discovered the first Trump administration had obtained lawmakers’ phone records as part of an investigation into media leaks.

In response to a question from Rep. Dan Goldman (D-N.Y.), Smith explained the phone data helped corroborate part of his case about how Trump used the riot at the Capitol to try to delay lawmakers from certifying his loss.

“We had evidence that the president had directed Rudy Giuliani, one of his co-conspirators, to contact members of Congress to try to further delay the proceedings and exploit the violence that happened in the Capitol,” Smith said. “We had evidence that those calls had happened. We wanted to get more evidence of that, to corroborate it for trial.”