Immigrants at three Florida detention facilities have been deprived of critical medical care — including access to vital medications like insulin as well as timely treatments for life-threatening conditions, according to a new report from Human Rights Watch.
In one account, a man named Chauhan says he was denied all his medications, including for diabetes and heart disease, and that he collapsed days later. In another, a man named Brian says he was denied an inhaler and began spitting up blood. And in a third, a woman named Andrea recalls another detainee vomiting green bile, losing consciousness and being rushed to the hospital for gallbladder surgery after staff initially ignored her symptoms.
The report — which examines conditions at Krome North Service Processing Center, Broward Transitional Center (BTC) and the Federal Detention Center (FDC) — highlights the inhumane treatment that advocates say immigrants have experienced in detention, and the dangers they’ve faced due to medical neglect.
It refers to some detainees by their full names and others by pseudonyms to protect them from retaliation.
“Some detainees described facing life-threatening delays or outright denial of medical treatment,” the report alleges. “This substandard medical care may have been linked to two deaths, one at Krome and one at BTC.”
The troubling findings about medical care were among several in the report, which also said that officers used excessive force and treated immigrants in degrading ways. Detainees reported being forced to eat food “like dogs” as their hands were shackled behind their backs, and they said that staff once threw stun grenades into a cell as immigrants protested how they were being treated.
Human Rights Watch said it contacted Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the federal Bureau of Prisons for responses to the immigrants’ accounts, as well as the private companies that run these detention facilities. It only received a response from Akima, a company that provides services for ICE at Krome, which said that it “cannot comment publicly” and that it operates its contracts to the “highest standards.”
Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security pushed back against the reports’ allegations in a statement to HuffPost.
“Any claim that there are subprime conditions at ICE detention centers are FALSE,” DHS Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs Tricia McLaughlin said.
The Human Rights Watch report is based on interviews with 11 immigrants who’ve been detained in the three Florida facilities, as well as interviews with the family members of seven immigrants who’ve been detained at these facilities. The group also spoke with 14 attorneys who have worked on immigrant rights cases related to these facilities.
The report details key problems with medical care, both when it comes to treatment for chronic conditions and when it comes to real-time responses to medical emergencies.
“Detention facility staff routinely denied individuals with diabetes, asthma, kidney conditions, and chronic pain their prescribed medications and access to doctors,” the report states.
Immigrants also detailed multiple instances when an emergency was overlooked entirely or treated much later.
“Staff were dismissive or abusive even when detainees were undergoing a visibly obvious medical crisis,” the report states.
A man named Juan details calling an officer at Krome to assist another detainee who appeared very sick, only to be told that processing needed to be completed before that person could receive medical care. “The next day the nurse came and examined him, and said he suffered high blood pressure and had probably had a [mild] heart attack,” Juan said.
Medical neglect at these facilities “may” be tied to the deaths of two detainees earlier this year, the report states.
In February, Maksym Chernyak, 44, died after experiencing bleeding in his brain, according to ICE. And in April, Mary Ange Blaise, 44, died after being diagnosed with elevated blood pressure and chronic kidney disease, ICE said.
In both instances, the facilities were slow to respond to their conditions, the report states. ICE, meanwhile, has contended that “at no time during detention is a detained illegal alien denied emergent care.”
“The deaths of Maksym Chernyak and Marie Ange Blaise underscore the deadly consequences of medical neglect and raise serious concerns regarding accountability,” the Human Rights Watch report states.
