Action News Wire

How To Protect Yourself While Filming ICE On Your Phone, In 7 Steps

"What Alex Pretti was doing is something that is important to keep doing,” one lawyer said.

How To Protect Yourself While Filming ICE On Your Phone, In 7 Steps

After Alex Pretti was fatally shot by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent in Minneapolis, eyewitness cellphone videos became a powerful tool to contradict the Trump administration’s version of what had happened.

The Trump administration called Pretti “an assassin,” but videos show Pretti helping a protester who got pepper sprayed before he is pinned to the ground and shot. The Department of Homeland Security initially alleged in a statement that Pretti approached officers with a handgun, which is not supported by publicly available videos that show him clearly holding a cellphone when officers approached him.

The videos of Pretti’s death sparked national outcry, and are the latest example of how eyewitness footage can hold the federal government accountable to their actions –– even when doing this constitutionally protected action can come with great personal risk.

People have the right to record law enforcement in public spaces under the First Amendment, but federal government officials have denounced people who do so. Last year, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said that videotaping agents when they are out on operations is “violence.” In response to HuffPost’s questions about its recording policy, ICE said in a statement: “The public has the right to peacefully record law enforcement operations from a safe location, as long as they do not impede law enforcement actions or endanger the safety of law enforcement officers.”

“The reality on the ground is that even if what you are doing is constitutionally protected, it doesn’t mean that DHS will treat you with respect and allow you to continue that activity,” said Nithya Nathan-Pineau, a policy attorney and strategist at the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, a nonprofit that advocates for immigrants’ rights.

When you observe ICE encounters, you could be targeted by the Trump administration or even killed. Right before Pretti was fatally shot by a ICE agent in Minneapolis, he was filming the officers with his cellphone. One ICE observer even said her Global Entry and Transportation Security Administration precheck privileges got revoked shortly after an ICE agent scanned her face.

Despite all these personal risks, what a phone’s camera can capture is powerful.

“There’s no guaranteed safe way to record ICE right now,” explained David Huerta, senior digital security trainer at Freedom of the Press Foundation. “There are ways to at least do so with as many safety measures as one could put in place.”

1. Before Filming, Prepare Yourself And Your Phone.

If you have a separate phone, you can make it a burner phone that doesn’t contain your contacts and personal information — but many of us just have one phone. In these cases, at least take off Face ID and make your screen unlock code long, random and unique, so that it’s harder for an agent to obtain the contents within your phone in case your device gets seized.

“The good thing about both iPhones and Android phone is that you have the ability to have alphanumeric codes, so you can have letters and numbers,” which make a password stronger, Huerta said. Here’s how to do so for iOS and Android.

If you plan to record on your smartphone, make sure your iOS updates or your Android updates are completely up to date “because that’s another protection against these kind of forensics analysis tools” that federal agents use to extract data from phones, Huerta said.

And don’t start filming by yourself. Do this kind of activity with neighbors on your block or in pairs. “I think that’s super important, because it also adds to the protection of the observers to have other observers there,” Nathan-Pineau said. “But obviously, Alex Pretti was part of a large group of observers. He was not alone,” and he was killed.

If multiple people film the same event, it also helps you against claims that what you recorded is fake or generated by artificial intelligence. “The one thing that AI has so much trouble doing is producing video of the exact same incident from different angles,” said Jaime Longoria, a senior research manager for the Disinformation Defense League, a network of intersectional organizations fighting disinformation. “So corroboration with other eyewitness media is the best.”

Demonstrators film a federal law enforcement agent in Minneapolis in January. Ideally, you would not be alone when you hit record, experts recommend.
Bloomberg via Getty Images
Demonstrators film a federal law enforcement agent in Minneapolis in January. Ideally, you would not be alone when you hit record, experts recommend.

2. While Filming, Narrate What You See For Verification Later.

Videos of ICE encounters generated by AI are rampant, which is why the choices in what you film and narrating what you see can be so important to proving that what you saw is actually real.

“Make sure to mention the time, the date and an approximate location, so that whoever is seeing this video can actually pin it down to a specific location or time during the day,” Longoria said. Filming landmarks and nearby road signs can also help verification teams determine when and where this video took place, he added.

If all this information sounds overwhelming to recall in a stressful situation, remember the SALUTE acronym that Nathan-Pineau teaches ICE observers to keep track of:

  • S is for size or strength. Note the number of officers or vehicles that you see.
  • A is for activity. Describe what you see officers doing, like whether they are creating a checkpoint or are pulling someone out of their car.
  • L is for location. Note whether this is happening in a Home Depot parking lot, for example. Make a point to share the street you are on.
  • U is for uniform. Share what uniforms the officers are wearing, and if they are masked or not.
  • T is for time or date. Note the time and day this encounter happened for video verification purposes.
  • E is for equipment of what kinds of weapons the officers are using. It’s helpful for ICE watch groups to know when officers are using special equipment like a battering ram, Nathan-Pineau said.

3. While Filming, Remember You’re There To Document.

Nathan-Pineau said she doesn’t encourage people to follow ICE officers back to their house. “You’re there to observe. You are not there to physically put yourself between the officer and the person being arrested. This is about documentation. This is about trying to support that individual and their family,” she said.

If an officer asks you to step back, comply with what they say and move back. “Say out loud, ‘I hear you, and I’m stepping back,’” Nathan-Pineau said. “And then you’re recording yourself saying that too. ...You’re getting both sides of that interaction.”

If you have an officer tell you that you can’t film them in a public space, “You can say, ‘I’m standing on a public sidewalk. I am allowed to stand here and film,’” Nathan-Pineau said.

4. While Filming, Ask The Person Being Arrested If They Want To Share Contact Info.

Ask the person who is being detained if they want to share their name and a phone number of whom to contact. This is important for letting families know what happened to their loved one who has suddenly disappeared.

“This immigration system moves fast. There is very limited access to counsel. The vast majority of people don’t have lawyers,” Nathan-Pineau said. “People are transferred from their local area to large detention centers that could be many states away. And if you don’t have a way to let your family know what happened to you, they may just be wondering until you finally get access to a phone.”

5. Focus Camera On Agents, Not People Being Detained.

A person records Gregory Bovino, the former commander-at-large of U.S. Border Patrol, at a gas station in Minneapolis.
Stephen Maturen via Getty Images
A person records Gregory Bovino, the former commander-at-large of U.S. Border Patrol, at a gas station in Minneapolis.

If you can, try not to capture the faces of people who are being detained for their privacy, but if you do capture a person’s face, Nathan-Pineau advises against immediately sharing that video without obscuring the detained person’s face in some way.

That’s also why experts advise against livestreaming video in general. “We don’t encourage streaming, because one: You may be exposing the identity of the person who’s being detained and arrested without their consent,” Nathan-Pineau said. “And it also is potentially creating an environment where officers may become hostile if they see that you’re streaming on a social media platform.”

6. Preserve Footage If Your Phone Gets Taken.

If you believe your phone is about to be seized by an officer, hit the stop button on the recording and turn the phone completely off. This “is probably the best protection, because then it’s in a fully encrypted state at that point,” Huerta said.

7. After Filming, Don’t Edit Your File.

A person films U.S. Customs and Border Patrol agents in Kenner, Louisiana.
ADAM GRAY via Getty Images
A person films U.S. Customs and Border Patrol agents in Kenner, Louisiana.

For verification purposes, you want to keep the original video intact. Do not edit videos in any way with cuts, text, overlays or any sort of voiceover. Don’t modify any of the metadata on your file or even change the file name on a recording. Taking these extra steps “makes a huge difference, because you want to make sure that you are dealing with an unmodified piece of media through and through,” Longoria said.

Ideally, sharing footage with an official channel like your local immigrant rights group or media organization (like HuffPost!) can help, because they can do this verifying for you and make editorial decisions on what to share. That way, they can “present this type of media with context before it goes into the public,” Longoria said. Sharing the video with a trusted group first also protects the identity of the eyewitness taking the video.

“If you are the person on the ground sending the video and you post from a personal account, that’s also a way for other folks to identify you and to potentially make you a target as well,” Longoria said.

Why Filming ICE Matters Despite Risks

"We are still seeing a huge interest in people who want to come out and protect their neighbors,” Nathan-Pineau said.
OCTAVIO JONES via Getty Images
"We are still seeing a huge interest in people who want to come out and protect their neighbors,” Nathan-Pineau said.

After a federal agent fatally shot Renee Good in her car in Minnesota, Gov. Tim Walz asked residents to “carry your phone with you at all times” and “hit record” when they see ICE agents in neighborhoods.

“Help us create a database of the atrocities against Minnesotans, not just to establish a record for posterity, but to bank evidence for future prosecution,” he said.

“It’s unfortunately a really scary time to be engaged in this work, but we are still seeing a huge interest in people who want to come out and protect their neighbors,” Nathan-Pineau said. She leads trainings on how to watch ICE for people in the Washington, D.C., metro area. Right after Pretti’s death, Nathan-Pineau saw attendance spike. More than 1,700 people signed up for a training with a capacity of 1,000.

“And I think that really says something about how many people feel that what Alex Pretti was doing is something that is important to keep doing,” Nathan-Pineau said.