Action News Wire

Gray Lady's Schizophrenic Mental Health Coverage

The Times deserves credit for documenting cruel and inhumane treatment of the mentally ill in China, but it would have been helpful if the paper of record had pointed out that violence typically has little to do with mental illness.

Why do we associate the mentally ill with violence?

Partly, it's because of movies like Psycho which leave people with the impression that the mentally ill are creepy loners who murder those they love.

Partly, it's because of media coverage of mass murders and other crimes where TV talking heads routinely inquire as to the perpetrator's mental health before they even consider the possibility that the perpetrator may have a criminal record.

And perhaps most significantly, it's because we want to believe that violence is not something that sane people commit. We forget, perhaps a bit too readily, that we all have within us the capacity to do good or ill; there is a dark side to human nature whether one believes that the Fall of Man is a metaphor or an actual event.

Fortunately, most of us do not give in to such impulses. We have been socialized into an adult world where extremely anti-social acts can lead to prison time.

Yet many of us persist in believing that crime is alien to humanity, that it is engaged in only by "deranged" people. We want to believe that we are better than the mentally ill, even though studies show that the mentally ill are more likely to be victims, than perpetrators, of violent crime.

That is why I had mixed feelings about the New York Times' recent two-part series on mental illness in China. On the one hand, I was thrilled that the Times exposed the overwhelming inadequacies of psychiatric care in that rogue regime where many sane political dissidents are brutally beaten and given electro-convulsive therapy or "shock" treatment against their will.

Such abusive behavior is no surprise for a country that a year ago executed a mentally ill man, Akmal Shaikh, a British citizen who according to reports had been duped into carrying drugs into China, a crime punishable by death there.

The Times should be applauded for its valuable reporting, for providing actual names and photographs of citizens who have been mistreated, and for gathering statistics on the number of Chinese cities, for instance, that have a mental health ordinance, 6 out of 283.

Sadly, not all of its coverage was so laudatory. Just about every time the Times made reference to a schizophrenic in the first part of its series, published on Nov. 11, it mentioned that the man had committed an act of violence, such as attacking kindergarteners with weapons. A spate of such attacks occurred in China earlier this year.

It is true that schizophrenics can become violent when they misread a situation, but it is troubling to me that the Times never balanced such cases with a discussion of other schizophrenics who have never committed violent acts. Perhaps, such information is hard to find in a country that often infringes upon freedom of the press, but the Times, in its otherwise thoughtful series, could have at least noted that the vast majority of violent crime in China, as in the U.S. and elsewhere, is not committed by the mentally ill.

Moreover, it might have questioned some of the diagnoses of these supposed schizophrenics.

Since the stigma against the mentally ill is particularly acute in China, there are probably fewer charlatans, like Brian David Mitchell, on trial now in federal court in Utah for kidnapping and repeatedly raping Elizabeth Smart, who claim to be insane. (Smart has testified persuasively that Mitchell is completely sane; he planned the crimes and, con man that he is, used religion and the threat of violence as a means of manipulating her into sex.) However, given the primitive nature of its facilities and its medical practitioners, China no doubt has a high, if not higher, percentage of people who have an incorrect diagnosis, as well as others who commit violent acts for a wide variety of reasons other than mental illness.

To repeat, the Times deserves credit for documenting cruel and inhumane treatment of the mentally ill in China, where social inequities are egregious and where citizens are denied basic human rights we take for granted here. But it would have been helpful if the paper of record had pointed out that violence resulting from financial, workplace and marital problems in China, as in our own country, typically has little to do with mental illness.