Action News Wire

Donald Trump’s New ‘Get Out Of Court Free’ Card

Trump keeps invoking national security to enact his policies — and it’s all a ploy to get more power.

Donald Trump’s New ‘Get Out Of Court Free’ Card

In just the past week, the Department of Veteran’s Affairs, the Environmental Protection Agency, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services and the Federal Emergency Management Agency canceled union contracts covering nearly 500,000 federal government workers. The reason: national security.

Since retaking office in January, President Donald Trump has often justified his expansive — and oftentimes illegal — view of executive branch power by invoking national security in policy announcements. To strip union protections from nearly 75% of the federal government workforce, he issued an executive order labeling numerous agencies as having national security as their primary responsibility, despite many of these agencies having little to do with traditional conceptions of national security.

Trump’s broad brush application of national security to his policies has a twofold purpose. First, many laws authorizing the president to take unilateral action require an assertion or declaration they are being invoked in defense of national security. And second, courts have long offered deference to presidents when they assert powers under the umbrella of national security or foreign affairs.

Decisions in Washington don’t just stay in Washington — they shape lives everywhere. HuffPost is committed to reporting on how policies affect real people. Support journalism that connects the dots. Join our membership program today.

The aim is to use these emergency powers and claims of national security threats to cement Trump’s unitary control of the government. With Congress in Trump’s pocket, the courts stand as the lone potential bulwark among the branches of government. But in declaring everything a national security threat, Trump hopes to bypass the courts by relying on these longstanding principles of deference on those issues to rule by decree.

“If everything can be a national emergency or a threat to national security or a matter of foreign policy, then essentially all constitutional powers are ceded to the president,” said Shirin Sinnar, a law professor at Stanford Law School. “And that can’t be intended by the constitutional design.” (Sinnar later clarified that not all powers would be ceded to the president, as even on matters of national security, the president’s authority is shared with, and can ostensibly be constrained by, Congress.)

But courts haven’t been so willing to grant Trump the blanket deference he desires. Federal district courts have tackled challenges to his policies with some acceptance, but, by and large, they have rejected Trump’s power grabs or found ways to rule without raising questions around the president’s national security powers.

“Overall, I think many courts have not been deferential here,” said Ilya Somin, law professor at George Mason University and a scholar at the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank. “When extraordinary powers are claimed, there has to be extraordinary proof that there really is a kind of emergency — invasion, national security threat or whatever the triggering factor is — otherwise, the executive can just use these sorts of powers whenever he feels like it.”

President Donald Trump has invoked national security to justify his autocratic policy agenda in the hopes that courts will defer to his authority.
President Donald Trump has invoked national security to justify his autocratic policy agenda in the hopes that courts will defer to his authority.
Mark Schiefelbein via Associated Press

Presidents have long invoked national security or emergency powers to act unilaterally, as President Joe Biden did when he attempted to forgive billions in student loan debt under emergency powers granted during the COVID-19 emergency. These assertions of national security powers have only grown as the national security state expanded and legislative gridlock and divided government have become the norm.

National security deference is not one single judicial doctrine, but a set of doctrines deployed by courts in varying circumstances. A couple of the most well-known and oft-cited are the state secrets privilege, which allows the executive branch to withhold certain information, and the political questions doctrine, which denies courts the ability to rule on cases that are purely political and left to the political branches.

“The ‘national security’ label tends to trigger judicial deference of varying degrees,” said Liza Goitein, senior director of the Brennan Center for Justice’s Liberty and National Security Program. “There’s no definition of what constitutes national security, so it’s far too easy for a president to slap the label on anything and everything in order to evade robust judicial review.”

And that is why Trump has gone so much further than previous presidents, invoking expansive powers often with no real emergency or national security threat at hand.

“What we had with Biden was an attempt to exploit what, by any measure, was a genuine emergency to enact policies that were actually just long-term policy objectives, but here we have Trump inventing completely bogus nonexistent emergencies to justify in some cases even larger power grabs,” Somin said.

This can be seen in Trump’s sweeping tariffs, deportation of immigrants, revocation of foreign student visas for speech, domestic deployment of the military, purges of government workers, decertification of government employee unions and attacks on law firms. When the administration offers explanations for what national security problems these orders are meant to address, the reasoning is often convoluted or nonsensical. In court filings defending many of these policies, the administration has declared that courts cannot question the president’s decisions or the facts justifying the president’s assertions of power and, in some cases, that they cannot hear the case at all. But district court judges have been, mostly, nonplussed with these demands for deference.

The most glaring example of this came on March 14 when Trump signed a proclamation invoking the Alien Enemies Act to designate members of the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua, as alien enemies with the intent to arrest, detain and remove immigrants labeled as gang members without due process. The Alien Enemies Act enables the president to target designated noncitizens with detention and removal in the event of an “invasion,” “declared war” or “predatory incursion” by a foreign nation. The order claimed the gang was “conducting irregular warfare and undertaking hostile actions against the United States,” despite the fact it is demonstrably not a foreign nation and is in fact largely decentralized.

New York State Assembly member Tony Simone holds a photo of Venezuelan makeup artist Andry Hernandez Romero as he protests against the deportation of immigrants to El Salvador.
New York State Assembly member Tony Simone holds a photo of Venezuelan makeup artist Andry Hernandez Romero as he protests against the deportation of immigrants to El Salvador.
Michael M. Santiago via Getty Images

Before publishing that proclamation publicly, the administration rounded up over 200 Venezuelans and Salvadorans it claimed were gang members, with little to no evidence, onto planes and prepared to send them into a megaprison in El Salvador without any notice or ability to challenge their detention.

When challenged in court the next day, Department of Justice lawyers refused to say anything about the three flights due to national security. This claim was a “heck of a stretch,” Judge James Boasberg said. After Boasberg ordered the flights to be turned around due to lack of due process provided to the detainees, the administration did not comply.

Boasberg then launched a contempt finding into whether the administration deliberately disobeyed his order with a series of questions. DOJ lawyers responded that the questions were “grave encroachments on core aspects of absolute and unreviewable Executive Branch authority relating to national security, foreign relations and foreign policy.”

The case was appealed up to the Supreme Court, which ruled Alien Enemies Act designees must be afforded due process. The court, however, declined to rule on whether the alien enemy designation was proper, noting that the law “largely ‘preclude[s] judicial review,’” but that such claims could be brought through individual writs of habeas corpus.

“Although judicial review under the AEA is limited, we have held that an individual subject to detention and removal under that statute is entitled to ‘judicial review’ as to ‘questions of interpretation and constitutionality’ of the Act as well as whether he or she ‘is in fact an alien enemy fourteen years of age or older,’” the decision states.

Habeas claims followed, leading to varying degrees of national security deference from district and appellate court judges on the question of whether courts could rule on the legality of Trump’s invocation of the Alien Enemies Act.

“[The administration] argue[s] that the courts are without power to review these findings,” Judge Alvin Hellerstein of the Southern District of New York wrote. “Courts, however, by their nature, interpret statutes.”

And so Hellerstein ruled that the Alien Enemies Act did not enable Trump’s proclamation because the act does not justify “a finding that refugees migrating from Venezuela, or TdA gangsters who infiltrate the migrants, are engaged in an ‘invasion’ or ‘predatory incursion.’”

In a district court in Colorado, Judge Charlotte Sweeney shot down each effort by the administration to force the court to defer to its judgment and not consider the question. The president’s powers over foreign policy are not disturbed because “interpreting and assessing the constitutionality of the Act in the context of Petitioners’ claims does not amount to ‘supplant[ing] a foreign policy decision of the political branches.’”

A California National Guard soldier stands guard outside of the federal building complex in downtown on June 17 in Los Angeles, California.
A California National Guard soldier stands guard outside of the federal building complex in downtown on June 17 in Los Angeles, California.
Scott Olson via Getty Images

Similarly, Judge Fernando Rodriguez, a district court judge in Texas, found that the proclamation’s assertion of an “invasion” or “predatory incursion” did not match the definition of those terms in the act, but also deferred to the administration by stating his court “may not adjudicate the veracity of the factual statements in the Proclamation, or the propriety of the steps taken by the President as to Venezuelan aliens and TdA members.” He also deferred to the administration on what it would do after his ruling defined the terms “invasion” and “predatory incursion.”

“The court having determined the meaning of these terms, it is left to the Executive Branch to determine whether a foreign nation or government has threatened or perpetrated activity that includes such an entry,” Rodriguez wrote.

In the Western District of Pennsylvania, Judge Stephanie Haines endorsed Rodriguez’s deference to the administration while offering a definition of “invasion” and “predatory incursion” that authorized Trump’s proclamation. Joining Haines in siding with the administration, Judge John Holcomb in the Central District of California offered full deference to Trump, writing that “when the President exercises his authority under the AEA, he ‘acts pursuant to an express or implied authorization of Congress,’ and the judiciary must defer to his judgment.”

These issues of national security and foreign affairs deference reared their head in the highly publicized case of Kilmar Abrego Garcia case, an undocumented Salvadoran immigrant who the administration admitted it had wrongly sent to the CECOT megaprison in El Salvador. The administration repeatedly claimed that they could not answer Judge Paula Xinis’ questions about Abrego Garcia’s confinement or what steps it would take to follow her order to “facilitate” his return by citing the president’s powers over national security and foreign affairs.

“What about national security is at issue? This is basically, ‘Take my word for it,’” Xinis said during one hearing in May.

Fights over national security deference have not been limited to immigration cases alone. And, as in the immigration cases, judges have been willing to, at least somewhat, push back on national security deference claims.

“I think there is more skepticism about the government’s assertions, but it doesn’t mean that courts are uniformly willing to challenge the factual basis on which the government is justifying some of its more extreme measures,” Sinnar said.

When Trump’s declarations of national security emergencies to impose sweeping tariffs on nearly every country were challenged in court, the administration claimed that the court could not even question his assertions that such an emergency existed.

The Court of International Trade ruled that Trump does not have "unbounded" authority to impose the worldwide and retaliatory tariffs he has issued by executive order.
The Court of International Trade ruled that Trump does not have "unbounded" authority to impose the worldwide and retaliatory tariffs he has issued by executive order.
Spencer Platt via Getty Images

The three-judge panel of the Court of International Trade rejected this demand for deference, claiming it could rule on the standards set out in the IEEPA “just as it ‘manages’ the standards for any other statutory enactment that constrains independent executive action.” It went on to strike down Trump’s tariffs as not authorized under that law for failing to “deal with” a national security threat, although an appeals court temporarily paused that decision.

“By the Government’s telling, the court cannot ever question the President’s assertion that his [International Emergency Economic Powers Act] authority ‘deal[s] with an unusual and extraordinary threat,’” the decision said.

Following protests against Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids in Los Angeles, Trump declared an emergency, calling the protests a “rebellion against the authority of the Government” and federalized the California National Guard to respond. California Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, sued to challenge the federalization of the guard as not predicated on any real emergency and for failing to issue orders through the governor as, he argued, is required by the governing statute.

During arguments over a temporary restraining order in June, DOJ lawyers claimed that courts could play no role in the matter as, “[this] is precisely the type of sensitive judgment that is committed to the president’s discretion by law.” They added that the president could declare some event a “rebellion against the authority of the Government” without any evidence at all and courts would not be able to rule on it.

Judge Charles Breyer rejected these arguments, while preserving the same deference toward “factual determinations” found in the Alien Enemies Act case heard by Rodriguez.

“[T]he Court here — like Judge Rodriguez in J.A.V. — does not question Defendants’ factual assertions,” Breyer wrote in granting the temporary restraining order. “The Court considers only whether those factual assertions, if true, constitute a rebellion or make the President unable to execute federal law.”

Breyer went on to note, with intentional emphasis, that “this case is not one involving the kind of foreign policy or national security questions that traditionally are left to the President. It instead implicates the President’s domestic use of military force, a matter on which the courts can certainly weigh in.”

Breyer’s ruling, however, was paused by an appeals court. The case was heard again last week.

Trump’s executive order directing the decertification of federal government worker unions also rests on assertions of national security. The law governing federal government worker union labor relations enables the president to authorize exceptions to which agency employees can unionize if national security is the primary purpose of an agency.

The conservative-dominated Supreme Court is likely to be the final arbiter on whether Trump deserves national security deference.
The conservative-dominated Supreme Court is likely to be the final arbiter on whether Trump deserves national security deference.
Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post via Getty Images

While past presidents have used this authority to exempt specific subagencies, like the Defense Intelligence Agency and the U.S. Army Intelligence and Security Command, Trump went further and exempted whole departments as well as subagencies. These included many with only a tangential tie to national security including the Department of the Treasury, EPA, Food and Drug Administration, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and Bureau of Land Management, among others.

Six government workers unions challenged the order in court as unconstitutional under the First and Fifth Amendments. As in other cases involving invocations of national security, the administration declared that courts could not question the president’s decision-making here and thus could not rule on this case. District Court Judge James Donato did not agree.

“Even with the deference due to the executive and legislative branches in matters of national security and defense, the judiciary may decide the question of constitutional limitations,” Donato wrote in a decision that struck down the order as retaliation for the unions’ speech under the First Amendment. But the Ninth Circuit Appeals Court reversed Donato’s decision.

As seen in many of these cases, initial decisions by district court judges who did not afford deference to Trump were put on pause by appellate courts. These cases are bound to continue in appeals courts and, considering the weighty issues involved, are likely headed to the Supreme Court — which in recent years has been eager to rule in Trump’s favor.

In the first Trump administration, the court relied on national security deference in its highly controversial decision in Trump v. Hawaii authorizing Trump’s first Muslim ban. The law authorizing the president to control noncitizen entry into the country “exudes deference to the President in every clause,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for five conservative justices on the court in 2018.

The Supreme Court, which has tilted even further to the right since Trump’s appointment of Justice Amy Coney Barrett in 2020, will be the ultimate decider in whether Trump’s even more audacious claims of emergency powers and national security can survive a challenge or if courts can even rule on them at all.

If not, the balance of the separation of powers would tilt almost exclusively to the president, enabling widespread emergency decrees without requiring any basis in actual reality.