Action News Wire

Donald Trump's Hush Money Trial, Week 5: Live Updates

The former president's criminal trial continues in New York.

Donald Trump's Hush Money Trial, Week 5: Live Updates

The jury overseeing Donald Trump’s criminal trial will hear more testimony in New York this week as it mulls the former president’s fate.

Trump faces 34 felony counts related to an alleged plot to cover up an accusation of an affair he had with porn actor Stormy Daniels about 10 years before he ran for president. The case, brought by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, accuses Trump and his team of a “catch and kill” scheme hatched alongside the National Enquirer to pay for and bury negative coverage about the Daniels affair and others.

The case centers on a $130,000 hush money payment to Daniels, who testified last week and then mocked Trump on social media over his failure as of yet to take the stand in his own defense.

Trump lawyer Michael Cohen — who was previously imprisoned over his role in the hush money plot — took the stand on Monday.

Judge Juan Merchan is on the bench presiding over the trial. Trump’s legal team includes Emil Bove, Todd Blanche and Susan Necheles. The prosecution includes Susan Hoffinger, Joshua Steinglass, Christopher Conroy and Matthew Colangelo.

Read live updates from the trial below:

Pinned

Day 18: Cohen Cross Continues. Also Penis Balloons.

  • The defense continued its cross-examination of Michael Cohen, attempting to cast doubt on his memory of events and calls from eight years ago. Cohen, who once estimated making 100 calls a day, said he specifically remembers the hush money payment conversations because they “were extremely important and all consuming.”

  • Blanche zeroed in on an Oct. 2016 call Cohen made to Trump’s bodyguard. Cohen maintains the call, which only lasted a minute and a half, served to inform Trump of the Stormy Daniels deal. But Blanche angrily disputed that, noting the short duration of the call, and that Cohen previously said he’d been getting harassing phone calls that night and wanted to flag the situation with Trump and his security. Cohen pushed back, saying he made such calls all the time.

  • Someone released around 100 metallic, pink penis balloons outside the courthouse this morning, dramatically stopping a U-Haul in the middle of the street and shoveling them en masse out the back. Each balloon featured a photo of District Attorney Alvin Bragg, Judge Juan Merchan or Special Counsel Jack Smith taped to both sides, suggesting it was a pro-Trump (albeit bizarre) stunt.

  • Just before court broke for the day, Blanche seemed to be gearing up an attack on the characterization of the payments themselves as “hush money,” noting the agreement with Daniels was “a completely legal, binding contract.”

  • Court is off tomorrow so Trump can attend his son Barron's high school graduation. We'll be back Monday.

Trump's Day Off The Court

Judge Juan Merchan agreed not to hold court today to allow Trump to attend his son Barron's high school graduation.

Following the event, Trump will visit Minnesota to campaign in the state, where he lost both in 2016 and 2020.

The Associated Press' Steve Karnowski has the details.

'A Grave Threat'

Former Republican Rep. David Jolly called out House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) and others for joining Trump's entourage at the Manhattan courthouse this week, saying the purpose of their visit was essentially to “try to interfere with the administration of justice.”

"To see the members of the House do that is a grave threat," he added.

Read more on Jolly's interview on MSNBC below.

Eric Swalwell Blasts 'Do-Nothing' Republicans

Rep. Eric Swalwell (D-Calif.) took issue with Republicans who chose to attend Trump's trial over a House Judiciary Committee hearing.

"I don’t think anything could animate the phrase ‘Do-Nothing Congress’ more than missing votes and canceling hearings to go up and be a spectator at your cult leader’s trial," he said.

Read more here:

Trump Reads Headlines Again After Court

As he’s made a habit of recently, Trump read headlines to the pool reporters gathered in the hallway outside the courtroom, using them as talking points to launch into broader attacks on the legitimacy of the case itself.

Unlike in previous days, however, Trump didn’t seem to have printouts of the actual articles — only the headlines.

One particular headline seemed to catch Trump off-guard.

“Ashton Kutcher’s going to pop up to tell us we’ve been punked!” he read. Then looking up confused, he said, “I think I know what that means.”

Trump also asserted that many people who are registered Democrats have changed their voter registrations as a result of the trial.

He did not answer reporters' questions about whether or not he would testify in his own defense.

Merchan Estimates That Presentations Could Wrap Monday

With just a couple more hours of testimony from Cohen expected next week, the defense will have the opportunity to call their own witnesses, but Trump's team told Merchan they would be fairly quick. (Still no word on whether Trump will take the stand, however.) The judge said it sounded like the parties could be done with their presentations by the end of Monday. Closing statements would then follow. Merchan asked both sides to be ready to present Tuesday, just in case.

Defense May Call Bob Costello As A Witness: Report

A source familiar with the defense team told CNN they may call Bob Costello to testify, although the plan hasn’t been finalized.

Cohen said Tuesday that Costello attempted to convince Cohen to hire him in 2018 as the hush money investigation began to take off. Cohen rejected the overture, saying Costello, who was close with Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani, was just a “back channel” for Trump to keep an eye on him from afar.

“I believed, based on all our conversations, he would immediately run back to Mr. Giuliani and that communication would be divulged to President Trump," he told jurors.

“There was something really sketchy and wrong about him,” he added.

We're Done For The Day

Merchan excused the jurors early today because one of them had a prior conflict, giving them the usual instructions to avoid information about the case. We'll reconvene Monday.

Blanche: Hush Money Was ‘Completely Legal’

Blanche brought up the fact that the payments to Daniels and McDougal have been referred to as “hush money.”

“Make no mistake, this was a completely legal, binding contract,” Blanche said, seemingly for the benefit of the jury. Cohen agreed with the statement.

The charges against Trump are related to fraudulent business records — in other words, it’s about the coverup.

Another Attack On Cohen’s Memory

Blanche took aim at another phone call Cohen testified about previously, this time from June 2016. He suggested that Cohen must have made tens of thousands of phone calls since that time, and asked why he would remember the conversation specifically.

“These phone calls are things that I’ve been talking about for the last six years. … They were extremely important and all-consuming,” Cohen testified, adding that he didn’t remember the exact times they occurred. He said that he put together what conversations he was having at the time based on other documentation that he consulted.

“I’ve been telling the same story about it for six years,” Cohen said.

Blanche repeated that skeptically, asking if Cohen had been talking about the same phone calls for six years. Cohen said again that the events were significant.

Lawyers Aren’t Supposed To Secretly Record Clients, Cohen Affirms

Blanche asked Cohen to affirm that it was not ethical of him, as Trump’s attorney, to record Trump without his knowledge and share it with a third party — as Cohen did with AMI CEO David Pecker.

That recording has been played and referenced multiple times in the trial. Cohen said he made the recording to convince Pecker he would get his money back from Trump.

Cohen Recalls Working With New York Times’ Maggie Haberman

While Blanche asked Cohen to affirm that he had relationships with lots of reporters, including Chris Cuomo and Katy Tur, he has turned his focus to Cohen’s relationship with New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman. Cohen affirmed that he had a “very strong” relationship with Haberman, and had on one occasion asked her to write a story about “how good it was” that Cohen would be Trump’s personal attorney while he was in the White House.

“I would use Ms. Haberman if the story was something that I believed the New York Times would run,” Cohen said.

Asked whether he informed people that he was recording them, Cohen said he did not, adding that it was not illegal to do so in New York (which is true). The recordings, he said, were useful to him in lieu of note-taking. Cohen estimated that he had recorded around 40 conversations with a handful of the same reporters.

Cohen Turns And Speaks Directly To Jurors

Answering a few questions about how he worked with journalists at the Trump Organization, Cohen turned to address the jury directly, something he has been doing on occasion. He explained how he would go about pitching to a specific reporter or go to Trump when he received a request for comment on a story.

Cohen explained what would happen if he replied to a journalist without consulting Trump, and Trump didn't like his response: "One, it'd cause him to blow up at me, and two, it'd probably mean the end of my job."

Harassment Cohen Experienced Discussed In More Detail

Blanche displayed a series of text messages for jurors between Cohen and an allegedly 14-year-old individual who was making harassing calls. When the individual once neglected to block their number, Cohen nabbed it and sent them a text.

“This number has just been sent to Secret Service,” Cohen said, reading the message he sent in October 2016. He received a series of replies: “My friend told me to call,” “I’m sorry for this” and “I won’t do it again.”

“You will need to explain this to Secret Service as we have been receiving dozens of phone calls over the last three days. If you are a minor, I suggest you notify your parent or guardian,” Cohen replied, reading his text aloud in court.

We're Back From Lunch

Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) rejoined the group trailing Trump into the courtroom following a lunch break.

100 Penis Balloons Released Outside The Trial, Apparently In Support Of Trump

A U-Haul just stopped in the street outside the Manhattan courthouse, where two men proceeded to usher dozens of phallic pink balloons out of the back, each adorned with a photo of someone involved in the trial.

District Attorney Alvin Bragg, Judge Juan Merchan and Special Counsel Jack Smith all appear to be among them. A reporter on scene estimated there were “nearly 100” of them.

“Penises!” one of the men shouted triumphantly, pointing upward as his handiwork floated away. “They’re all penises!”

Trump Attorney’s Dull Examination Crescendos Into Dramatic Scene Just Before Lunch

Shouting now, Blanche is hounding Cohen about the October 2016 phone call, accusing him of lying about its purpose.

Blanche had gotten Cohen to affirm, after refreshing his memory, that he was dealing with some harassing phone calls and wanted to flag the situation with Trump and his security. (The harasser allegedly claimed to be 14 years old.)

Blanche suggested that the short length of Cohen’s call to bodyguard Schiller — only about 1 minute and 30 seconds — was not enough time to inform Trump about the harassment and discuss the Stormy Daniels situation. But Cohen pushed back, saying he made such calls all the time.

“Always ran everything by the boss immediately,” Cohen said, adding that it could be a short message like “everything’s taken care of."

Later, Blanche told Cohen harshly, “We are not asking for your belief. This jury does not want to hear what you think happened,” before being cut off by an objection that was sustained.

We have reached our lunch break.

We Return To An October 2016 Phone Call

Blanche is drilling down on a particular phone call in an attempt to impeach Cohen’s credibility.

On Oct. 24, 2016, Cohen testified, he called bodyguard Keith Schiller to speak to Trump, knowing the two were together, because Trump wanted to pass along a message about the resolution of the Stormy Daniels hush money situation. Cohen could not recall whether Schiller passed the phone to Trump in the moment or put him on speakerphone.

The call is important because it helps illustrate Cohen was acting on Trump’s behalf — not going rogue.

Checking In On The Jury

While jurors still appear to be following the testimony, they have largely stopped taking notes for Blanche's cross-examination. A couple of them cast a wandering eye out over the public gallery.

Freedom Caucus Members Heckled By Protesters Outside NYC Courthouse

Most of Trump’s Republican entourage didn’t return to the courthouse after the morning break, instead decamping to the television cameras outside.

On a livestream relayed by the Associated Press, Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz (R) introduced members of the House Freedom Caucus one by one, and they echoed the same lines Trump often repeats after court every day.

A protester who appeared to be standing behind the designated barrier interrupted the grandstanding, holding up a sign that read “BOOTLICKERS” on one side and “GTFO NYC MAGA” on the other. Security ushered the man away, ignoring his arguments about being on the correct side of the fence.

The Trump allies then continued their news conference, raising their voices at times as shouting from afar drowned them out.

Many of the Republicans ventured into territory that could violate Trump’s gag order, attacking both family members of the court and witnesses in the trial. Gaetz seemed to acknowledge that in his remarks.

“There are things we can say that president Trump is unjustly not allowed to say,” he said. “This is a corrupt judge. These are corrupted witnesses. This is a corrupt prosecution that belies any sense of the facts or the law.”

In addition to barring him from attacking witnesses, Trump’s order prohibits him from causing others to make them on his behalf.

Blanche Homes In On The Idea Cohen Had Political Aspirations Despite Repeated Pushback

“You really wanted to work in the White House, correct?” Blanche asked.

“No, sir,” Cohen said. He repeated this answer when Blanche rephrased the question a couple of times. Cohen has said he wanted to be asked to be Trump’s chief of staff to appease his ego but that he never really wanted a big job in Washington.

“You told your daughter you were disappointed?” Blanche asked.

“That I wasn’t considered? Yes, sir,” Cohen said.

A couple of minutes later, facing more questions about his conversations with his daughter, Cohen told Blanche: “I don’t think you’re characterizing this correctly at all.”

"If you look at my conversations with my daughter, I turn around and say to her, 'I'm not the right person for chief of staff,'" Cohen testified. He has now stressed many times that the title he sought, and eventually received, was "personal attorney to the president," saying it slowly for emphasis.

“You were not embarrassed that after all the work you’d done for him, you were left being his personal attorney and nothing more?"

“That’s the role that I wanted,” Cohen testified.

Trump Attorney Suggests Cohen Shirks Responsibility

Continuing to try chipping away at Cohen’s image as a reformed man who has owned up to his mistakes, Blanche is emphasizing how Cohen has been petitioning a federal court to end his period of supervised release early. (Cohen was originally sentenced to 36 months’ imprisonment followed by three years of supervised release.) Cohen affirms he has made three to four attempts to do so, in part because he is a cooperating witness.