Ukraine has U.S. weapons it can't use in Russian territory. Will that change? - Action News
Home WebMail Friday, November 22, 2024, 10:42 AM | Calgary | -10.8°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
World

Ukraine has U.S. weapons it can't use in Russian territory. Will that change?

Ukraine is trying to fend off aRussian offensivein the northeastern border region of Kharkiv, but it can only use its U.S.-provided firepower on its own side of the border when trying to thwart attacks.

U.S. policy prohibits Ukraine from using U.S.-provided weapons to hit targets in Russia

Smoke is seen rising in Kharkiv, Ukraine, in the aftermath of a Russian attack.
Smoke is seen rising in Kharkiv, Ukraine, in the aftermath of a Russian attack on Friday. Ukraine is trying to fend off aRussian offensivein the northeastern border region, but it can only use its U.S.-provided firepower on its own side of the border when trying to thwart attacks. (Evgeniy Maloletka/The Associated Press)

Ukraine is trying to fend off aRussian offensivein the northeastern border region of Kharkiv, but it can only use its U.S.-provided firepower on its own side of the border when trying to thwart attacks.

That's because Washington has put guardrails around where its weapons are to be used, and that is in Ukraine only though the pressure is building for the U.S. to give Kyiv a freer hand to operate.

Ukrainian politicians travelled to the U.S. capital this week to press the Biden administration to change its thinkingon the issue.And the U.S. Helsinki Commission, a federal agency that promotes human rights and military security,said the U.S. should "not only allow, but encourage" Ukraine to use theseweaponsacross the Russian border.

WATCH | Stark warning from Ukraine's PM:

Ukrainian PM warns that Ukraine losing would lead to a third world war

4 months ago
Duration 1:05
Ukraine's Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal tells Rosemary Barton Live that Ukraine and its allies are on the same page about the stakes of Russias war on Ukraine and says Ukraine is protecting the borders of the civilized world.

But analysts don't necessarily see Kyiv as being likely to get the sign-off it's seeking, given Washington's worries over escalation risks and the so-called red linesaroundthe conflict that NATO will stay out of Russia, but also will defend "every inch" of its members' territory. Though Ukraine is not part ofNATO,it lies on the edge of several members of the military alliance.

"These constraints were established right at the beginning," said Janice Stein, a foreign policy expert andthe Belzberg professor of conflict management at the University of Toronto."And so far, they are being respected."

Together, those conditionsleave Ukraine trying to manage the threats against it without crossing those same red lines.

"This whole conflict has been driven by the U.S. policy to try to help Ukraine defend, without getting into a confrontation with Russia by helping Ukraine attack," Wesley Clark, a retired U.S. general andformer supreme commander of NATO, told CNN. "And so, Ukraine is being forced back. Its forces are being bled out."

A destroyed tank is seen on a road in Ukraine's Kharkiv Region.
A destroyed tank is seen on a road in Ukraine's Kharkiv region on Thursday. (Valentyn Ogirenko/Reuters)

Added stress for Kyiv

Kyivrushedreinforcements to theKharkiv region amid a wave of Russian attacks includingairstrikes, shelling and troops on the ground thathave forced thousands of Ukrainians living near the borderto flee.

The fighting has been fierce, with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy telling ABC News that hundreds of Ukrainian soldiers have been wounded in recent days.

A handout photo from the Ukrainian Presidential Press Service shows Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy attending a meeting with military officials in Ukraine's Kharkiv region on Thursday, May 16, 2024.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy attends a meeting with military officials in Ukraine's Kharkiv region on Thursday. Zelenskyy told ABC News that hundreds of Ukrainian soldiers have been wounded in recent days. (Ukrainian Presidential Press Service/Reuters)

"A lot of guys gave their lives," Zelenskyy told the network Thursday, the day he met with military leaders in Kharkiv and visited injured soldiers.

Ukrainian officials say the armed forces havestopped Russian advancements in Kharkiv, andNATO's top commander, Gen. Christopher Cavoli,has said Russia does not have sufficient forces in place to make "a strategicbreakthrough" there.

Homes are seen burning in Vovchansk, Ukraine, following Russian airstrikes on Saturday, May 11, 2024.
Homes are seen burning in Vovchansk, Ukraine, following Russian airstrikes that occurred last Saturday. (Evgeniy Maloletka/The Associated Press)

Yet Russian President Vladimir Putin claimed Friday that his forces are aiming to create a buffer zone against Ukrainian attacks on theRussian Belgorod region, which he saidwere the reason for the Kharkiv offensive.

And he saidMoscow has no plans to capture the city of Kharkivitself, the regional capital.

'A predictable crisis'

The U of T's Stein saidUkraine is dealing with the urgent problems in Kharkiv despite dwindling air-defence supplies and ammunition, which Western allies are working to replenish but which should have happened sooner.

"This was a predictable crisis," said Stein, who believes Ukraine is likely to similarly face a tough summer, as Russia presses its advantage against its outgunned neighbour.

WATCH | Cameron backs use of U.K.-provided weapons inRussia:

U.K. foreign secretary says Ukraine can use British weapons inside Russia

4 months ago
Duration 2:02
Ukraine is eagerly waiting for Western aid as Russia racks up more victories on the battlefield. Meanwhile, British Foreign Secretary David Cameron on a visit to Kyiv gave Ukraine the go-ahead to use British weapons to strike directly at Russia.

Ukraine's military challenges aren't limited to the equipment it needs to oust Russian forces from its lands, but also the people it needs on the front line. The government has faced hard choices in deciding who to callto join the fight, and has ended up lowering the age that men can be drafted for the military.

Getting new troops battle-ready carries an escalation concern, as well: The New York Times reported that NATO is eyeing sending its trainers directly into Ukraine, to help prepare incoming soldiers closer to the frontlinerather than from facilities outside the country.

Pressure, but no policy change

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken visitedKyiv this past week, arriving days after the assault on Kharkiv began.

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken (left) is seen speaking at a news conference in Kyiv, alongside his Ukrainian counterpart, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba.
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken (left), is seen speaking in Kyiv on Wednesday, alongside his Ukrainian counterpart, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba. (Efrem Lukatsky/The Associated Press)

When asked about the issue of the Washington-sent weapons, the diplomatgave an ambiguous answer.

"We have not encouraged or enabled strikes outside of Ukraine, but ultimately, Ukraine has to make decisions for itself about how it's going to conduct this war," he said.

"And we will continue to back Ukraine with the equipment that it needs to succeed that it needs to win."

Blinken's answer may havegiven the impression ofa potentialshift,but a day later, a U.S. State Department spokespersontold a press briefingthatU.S. policy on the matter had not changed. And on Friday, White House national spokesperson John Kirby further affirmed that the Biden administrationdoes not encourage or enable attacks with U.S.-supplied weapons inside Russia.

Tymofiy Mylovanov, a former Ukrainian economy minister, saidBlinken'searlier comments suggest Washington is at least hearing the feedback on the issue.

"My hunch is that the policy has not changed, but they are now under pressure and considering changing and realizing it,"Mylovanovsaid via email.

A large column of smoke is seen rising in Kharkiv, Ukraine, in the aftermath of a Russian missile strike on Friday, May 17, 2024.
A large column of smoke in Kharkiv, in the aftermath of a Russian missile strike on Friday. (Valentyn Ogirenko/Reuters)

A policy changewould allow Ukraine to deal with Russian threats from afar, including targeting groupings of Russia troops, tanks and supplies before they cross the border, he said.

"We need the U.S. missiles to strike those locations because they are faster, have higher payload and more difficult to intercept," Mylovanov said.

George Barros, the Russia team lead at the U.S.-based Institute for the Study of War think-tank, agrees that the U.S. should allow for Ukraine to strike threats outside its border.

"The policy debate is approaching a pivotal moment," he told CBC News via email. "I hope the administration changes the policy sooner, rather than later."

In terms of possible escalation risks if this were to happen, Barros said there is "very little that Putin can do the escalate his war in Ukraine that he has not already done."

With files from The Associated Press and Reuters