What should happen to the Senate?

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is framing the appointment of seven new senators as the "next steps" in the Liberal promise to reform the Senate.

• Chantal Petitclerc, Murray Sinclair among 7 new Trudeau-appointed senators
• Liberal plan to pick 'non-partisan' senators draws quick criticism

"The government is today taking further concrete steps to follow through on its commitment to reform the Senate, restore public trust, and bring an end to partisanship in the appointments process," he said in a statement.

Conservatives say nothing has changed, with two MPs slamming the secrecy of the "tired, undemocratic process."Meanwhile,the NDP calls the Senate an "archaic institution" andstill wants the Senateabolished.

What should happen to the Senate?

Readers let usknow in the latest CBC Forum a live, hosted event about topics of national interest.

(Please note that user names are not necessarily thenames of commenters. Some comments have been alteredto correct spelling andto conform to CBC style. Click on the user name to see the comment in the blog format.)

"It's supposed to be a place where those representing the best interests of the country alter or reject legislation.If we can make it into that a house of sober second thought with our best interests in mind then we ought to keep it." Alex Polley

"I think the senators should be either appointed by the provinces, or perhaps even be ajuriedSenate, with no political parties involved they should all be independent." Neotribe

"Devolve the authority to thelieutenants-governorof the provinces. They know (or should know) the best people to represent the interests of the provinces. It will remain partisan as long thepower rests with the PM." Ken Hansen

"Maintain a non-partisan committee to vet candidates nominated by the public and create shortlists for candidate pools for each province. These candidates are to be eligible based on merit alone, and there are plenty of highly qualified and intelligent Canadians available...The shortlist is made available to the public, and an online public vote conducted to determine a super shortlist of three candidates per seat. The prime minister is mandated to select one of these three to present to the governor general for appointment." Morgantis

"The Senate in its current form is an outdated, unaccountableand unnecessary part of our governmental system. Abolition has to be the ultimate goal, but that is something that will require pan-Canadian cooperation and thus will require some time. Some immediate steps that should be taken are to reduce the financial burden on the taxpayer by reducing Senate salaries and expense accounts while at the same time setting some firm rules about spending and providing for independent oversight of such spending." CoryJudson

"Scandals. Patronage. Absenteeism. That's what people think of when they hear the word Senate. Cut the taxpayer a break and get rid of it." Lemansky

Can't see the forum? Click here.