Liberal ads target Tories' management of the economy ahead of Thanksgiving weekend

Ad Hawk is an occasional series evaluating the effectiveness ofpolitical advertising.

Two ads recently released by the Liberal Party challenge Stephen Harper and the Conservatives on their management of the economy. Together, the ads position Trudeau as the leader who would truly support the middle class and the Liberals as the party that would represent "real change" for Canadians.

• Ad Hawk: Read more critiques of the political ads

What's the message?

The first ad opens with a clip of Harper saying the Canadian middle class "has had good growth over the past few years" before immediately transitioning toTrudeau pronouncingHarper is out of touch with middle-class Canadians and doesn't "feel" their hardships.

Note: Ads are produced by the candidates, their parties or their agents. They are embedded here for informational purposes only and their placement does not constitute an endorsement by CBC News.

The second ad states thatHarper has had 10 years to get the economy moving but has failed to do so. Much likeTrudeau's previous escalator ad, the Liberals are once again utilizing a smart and simple visual mnemonic to express their message. This time, an expanding mosaic of videos ofHarper repeatedly buttoning his jacket is accompanied by a voiceover alluding to the expression that doing the same thing over and over is the definition of insanity.

The message of the two ads taken together? A vote for Harper is a vote for the stagnation of the economy and will continue to visit woes upon a struggling Canadian middle class.

Why now?

Trudeau has been a bit of a slow burn over the past few months, putting forward a solid social media campaign, performing more strongly in the debatesthan was predicted, and managing to overcome some on-camera blunders.

Given this, with the election just 12 days away and the competition looking increasingly like a two-party race, Liberal communications are bound to heat up. The objective is likely to give Canadian families clear discussion points for their Thanksgiving dinners this weekend.

Kernel of truth?

Wrapping economic arguments in rhetoric suggestingHarper is unsympathetic to the everyman is a smart strategy. Connecting emotionally with Canadians has been one of Trudeau's consistent strengths and one of Harper's consistent weaknesses.

It's also an interesting strategy given the Conservatives have long painted Trudeau as having been born with a silver spoon in his mouth. Perhaps Trudeau's intent is to remove it and place it squarely inside Harper'sinstead?

Rating: While the script for "Out of Touch" is solid and the visuals for "Over and Over" are clear and concise, these communications may not be critical enough to do major damage this late in the game. For the Liberals to get a clear edge over the Conservatives in advance of Oct.19, they may need to throw some harder-hitting punches. I give each ad about a 7/10.

Kerry McKibbin is a Group Account Director at Zulu Alpha Kilo, a Toronto-based advertising agency.Kerryhas worked on some of Canada's biggest brands and campaigns andspecializes in multi-channel communications including digital and social media strategy.