Toronto bans plastic bags by 2013

Toronto city council has voted to banplastic bagsoutright by 2013.

Council had spent Wednesday at city halldebatingwhether toeliminate a mandatoryfive-cent bag fee that Mayor Rob Fordhad wanted axed.

A majority of councillors decided to kill the bag fee by July 1 of this year, butWillowdale Coun. David Shiner also made a motionto eliminate plasticbagsaltogether by Jan. 1.His motion passed 24-20.

"It's better than just trying to get rid of the fee; it's getting rid of the bags," Shiner said.

Shiner said he wasn't planning on moving a motion to ban plastic bags until he saw it might pass."It's the most progressive move that this council's ever had," he said, adding that retailers should provide paper bags free of charge.

The mayorportrayed the outright ban as a victory. "We got rid of the bag tax; it's what people wanted," he said.

Ford and some councillors had argued that the $5 million retailers earned annually from the fee wasn't going to any particular environmental group and had served its purpose, cutting plastic-bag consumption in half.

The mayor believesthe ban will face legal hurdles.

"I don't think it will be upheld in court," he said. "Ajudge will just say, 'You can't tell these people they can't give out plastic bags or sell plastic bags.' To me it's ludicrous."

Los Angeles and Seattle areamong the otherNorth American cities that have taken similar approaches. Shiner said he got the idea from Seattle's recent ban.