Montreal won't outfit its police officers with body cameras

Mayor Valrie Plante has decided not to provide Montreal police officers with body cameras, saying the devices would be too costly for the city.

"We heardthe pros and the cons, but our position at this time is not to go ahead with body cameras," she said at this morning's executive committee meeting.

After a year-long pilot project, theMontreal police service released areport last weekconcludingbody cameras have little impact on interventions, present logistical challengesandleave officers feeling as if they'reunder surveillance.

The report said outfitting police with body cameraswould cost $17.4 million over five years andanother $24 million annuallyto run, given the labour and equipment costs involved.

Axon, the company that provided the SPVM with body cameras for thepilot project, has said the SPVM'sestimate is inflated.

The company has outfitted thousands of police officers with body cameras, in cities from Los Angeles to London.

Questions of transparency and trust

Lionel Perez, leader ofEnsembleMontral, criticized Plante'sdecision. He said thecosts arelikely less than estimated by theSPVM,and"reliable technology exists."

"She is disconnected from the population and its cultural communities," he said in a tweet.

Plantesaid there are other ways to ensure police gain the trust of the community, citing the police's plan to curb racial profiling announced last year.

In the U.S., the use ofbodycamerasin police departments has exploded in recent years, in part as a way to address transparency concerns amid tensions over killings of unarmed black men by officers.

But Canadian cities have, for the most part, been slow to follow suit.

Erick Laming,a doctoral student in criminology at theUniversity of Toronto, said Montreal's decision is not surprising. Edmonton and Toronto have also been reluctant to move forward with body cameras, he said.

In an interview with CBC Montreal'sRadio Noon, Laming said recent research suggests cameras aren't necessarily the "main factor" in encouraging transparency andaccountability.

"There's been more and more studies that have come out that show mixed results," he said.