Montreal mayor faces criticism for blocking comments on social media accounts

Montreal Mayor ValriePlante's decision to restrict access to her social media accounts is facing pushback over concerns it could stifle criticism.

Aref Salem, leader of the city's Official Opposition, says Plante and her party, Projet Montral, are limiting Montrealers' freedom of expression by blocking comments on social media platforms X and Instagram.

"This is not the way of democracy," he said in an interview Tuesday. "This is really unethical, even, to not let the population of Montreal interact with the mayor."

Salem says social media is one of the only ways for citizens to interact with Plante. Residents can voice their concerns in person during a question period at city council meetings, but they have only 90 seconds to ask their question.

"Having a social media feed is to connect with the population and ask the population about their opinion," he said. "It has to be an interaction."

Currently, the X accounts of Plante and Projet Montral only allow comments from people or organizations mentioned in the accounts' posts. Comments on Plante's Instagram posts are also limited, and it's not possible to tag her in an Instagram story.

On Wednesday, Plante said in a post on X that she made the decision to close comments because her replieshave been "dominated" by abusive language for months.

"Some may think there's a fundamental right to call a person an 'idiot' or a 'bitch' and to normalize violence online. I don't think so."

Salem said elected officials have an obligation to engage with their constituents. He said Plante could deal with online harassment by blocking individual accounts or reporting them to the police.

"When we decide to be public figures, that goes with the position," he said. "When we want to be representative of the population, we have to be representative of the whole population."

Anas Bussires McNicoll, director of the fundamental freedoms program at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, said a "blanket prohibition on comment" is an unreasonable limitation of people's freedom of expression. Instead, she said, elected officials should evaluate inappropriate comments on a case-by-case basis.

"I would say that elected officials with significant resources shouldn't have their cake and eat it too," she said. "In that if they choose to have access to and to use social media platforms in the context of their public work, they should also accept that their constituents might want to comment on their work on that very public platform."

In June, the Quebec government passed a law that includes fines of up to $1,500 for anyone who intimidates or harasses a politician, despite criticism that the legislation could threaten free speech.

Who has the right to reply?

Plante is not the first politician to block comments on social media accounts. Federal MPs of all political stripes have restricted comments on their X accounts, including Conservative MP Michelle Rempel Garner, Liberal MP Adam van Koeverden and NDP MP Laurel Collins.

Last year, the Governor General's office announced publicly that it was turning off comments on all of its social media accounts due to "an increase in abusive, misogynistic and racist engagement on social media and online platforms, including a greater number of violent threats."

Gov. Gen. Mary Simon, the first Indigenous person to hold the position, was appointed in 2021.

Though the issue of restricting comments has not received widespread attention, there has been considerable public debate about whether politicians have the right to block individual accounts, thereby preventing users from seeing their posts altogether.

In 2018, three Ottawa residents sought a court order declaring that then-mayor Jim Watson infringed their constitutional right to freedom of expression when he blocked them from his feed on the social media platform then called Twitter now X. Watson eventually settled the case by unblocking all accounts, and said he agreed that his Twitter feed was in fact a public account.

Last September, a Federal Court judge ordered Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault to unblock Rebel News founder Ezra Levant on X after the right-wing media personality claimed the minister was limiting his ability to engage in debate on matters of public concern.

South of the border, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled earlier this year that government officials who block critics on social media can sometimes be sued for violating the Constitution's First Amendment.