As AI becomes more popular, how are Western University students using ChatGPT? - Action News
Home WebMail Friday, November 22, 2024, 05:35 PM | Calgary | -11.1°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
London

As AI becomes more popular, how are Western University students using ChatGPT?

Concerns about artificial intelligence (AI) tools like ChatGPTbecoming a way to cheat are top of mind for professors. But some Western University students say the bot is better used as atool to help with ideas, rather than plagiarizing their assignments.

'We want to evaluate writing that comes from students, not AI,' says assistant professor

From left to right: Friends Parveer Sekhon, Ameya Patel, and Ishaan Aujla say ChatGPT can be a helpful resource to filter information, but in the long-run using the AI tool to cheat on assignments won't work too well.
From left to right: Friends Parveer Sekhon, Ameya Patel, and Ishaan Aujla say ChatGPT can be a helpful resource to filter information, but in the long-run using the AI tool to cheat on assignments won't work too well. (Isha Bhargava/CBC)

Concerns about artificial intelligence (AI) tools such asChatGPTbecoming a means of cheating are top of mind for professors,but some Western University students say they usethe botas atool to help them with ideas for their assignments, rather than to plagiarize.

"It almost acts like a search engine for us. It spits out information that you wouldn't easily be able to find on Google," said Ameya Patel, a health sciences student entering his second year.

"ChatGPTgives you one definitive answer, so it's like talking to a human.It's very easy to use when you're looking for certain information," the 19-year-old added.

The AI language program takes texts from the Internet and uses prompts to generate sentences and paragraphs that can seem very human-like. As its popularity has increased in recent months, so have the worries of educators,who fear it may inspire students to take shortcuts and rely on the tool to complete assignments.

"All these mechanisms are kind of 180 degrees against what we're trying to teach with writing," said Luke Stark, an assistant professor in thefaculty of information andmedia studies at Western.

"One of the dangers in the classroom is it'll get students used to avoiding those hard moments where you have to push through to write something."

A Western student on her phone
Western student Yueun Lee studies Media, Information and Technoculture. She says it's easy to tell what's AI-generated in her peers' work through the use of repetitive and formal words most university students wouldn't use. (Isha Bhargava/CBC)

But that hasn't stopped students from using ChatGPT. Computer Science studentParveer Sekhon said he knows plenty of university students who use it on a regular basis.

Many in his program use ChatGPT to write code but it's important to remember that the information a bot spits out may not be accurate.

"It's a competitive advantage, for sure, but it affects education," said Sekhon, 19. "I think it's best used not in terms of doing an entire assignment, but if you can't figure something out, you canuse it to help add on, but you also have to use your own intuition."

Along with classwork, ChatGPT also allows studentsto learn new skills and acquire information, and get some help with writing cover letters, Sekhon said.

Business student Ishaan Aujla, 19, said he believes using ChatGPT to cheat and get better grades will ultimately backfire.

"If someone uses it and gets the better mark for themselves, they'll suffer consequences because you can get a degree using ChatGPT, but when you go into the workforceyou'll be screwed," Aujla said.

Highlighting drawbacks of relying on AI

Luke Stark is an assistant professor at the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at Western University and his research focuses on artificial intelligence.
Luke Stark is an assistant professor at the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at Western University and his research focuses on artificial intelligence. (Starkcontrast.co)

Western has been encouraging instructorsto talk to their students about both the benefits and drawbacks of AI content generators such as ChatGPT, and to set clear expectations about its use in their courses. Currently, there's no reliable tool to detect whether AI has been used in assignments.

Professors should emphasize to students why they're asked to do certain assignments in the first place, and help them understand why it's in their best interest to not rely so heavily on AI, Stark said.

"We want to evaluate writing that comes from students, not AI, and I'm confident thatif we have conversations with students and engage with them, they can abide by the rules," he said. "The majority of students do understand why they're in university."

Repetitive and formal words that most university students wouldn't use are telltale signs that someon has used ChatGPT to complete an assignment, saidYueun Lee, who studies media, information and technoculture at Western. Relying on help fromAI longterm couldhave negative consequences, she added.

"Becoming too heavily reliant on any type of mechanics or AI is harmful becausethen you lose your own ability to do it. And if someday it just disappeared, people won't be able to write their essays anymore," she said.