B.C. wants pets to be treated more like humans and less like property in divorce proceedings - Action News
Home WebMail Friday, November 22, 2024, 02:39 PM | Calgary | -10.4°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
British Columbia

B.C. wants pets to be treated more like humans and less like property in divorce proceedings

Call it purr-fect legislation or a looming cat-astrophe but the new legislationis no laughing matter to those who have dealt with the issue for decades.

'It's a grey area,' says animal legal expert, noting custody disputes have grown during the pandemic

Canadian animal lawyers say they've seen a large spike in the number of pet custody cases over the past two years, as separating couples fight over who gets to keep the family pet.
Canadian animal lawyers say they've seen a large spike in the number of pet custody cases over the past two years, as separating couples fight over who gets to keep the family pet. (juste.dcv/Shutterstock)

Who gets the pet in a divorce?

It can be a contentious discussion in any breakup but how judges deal with such disputes in British Columbia could soon change.

Attorney General Niki Sharma introducedamendments to the province's Family Law Act on Monday, changing the guidance given to judges on what to consider in determining custody,includingeach person's ability and willingness to care for a pet, the relationship a child has with the animal and the risk of family violence or threat of cruelty.

"We know pets across the province are really loved members of a family," said Sharma.

"Theamendments make it easier for people to come up with their own agreements with how to divide time with the family pet, or if they can't, to get an order from a judge."

It's a change from how animals have traditionally been considered in divorce proceedings across Canada, where they have been explicitly treated as any other type of property.

Portrait of woman with dark hair and glasses.
Victoria Shroff is a Vancouver-based animal law lawyer who has seen an increase in cases involving emotional support pets during the pandemic. (Submitted by Victoria Shroff )

'Kind of a grey area'

Call it purr-fect legislation or a looming cat-astrophe but the new legislationis no laughing matter to those who have dealt with the issue for decades.

"It's groundbreaking for addressing the notion that animals are family members and not just a piece of furniture," said Victoria Shroff, a lawyer who has dealt with animal disputes for 23 years.

Shroff says that there has been a spike in battles over animal custody in recent years, and judges have had limited guidance on how to deal with what can be highly emotional debates.

As a result, different judges and tribunals have taken different approaches in a variety of cases that have attracted media attention.

"It's been kind of a grey area," said Shroff.

"There's been a disconnect between how at home animals are family, but in the court they're property ...it's time we addressed the issue as looking at an animal as more than some thing, and instead as some one, as a sentientbeing, as a part of our family."